287. “We’re trying for a baby, but 92% of our income is already spent. now what?”

]]>

Ramit Sethi unpacks why a couple making roughly $197K a year is trying for a baby while 92% of their take-home pay goes towards fixed costs and nearly every argument comes back to money.

Ramit Sethi of I Will Teach You to Be Rich talks with Zoe (42) and Sean (33), who have been together for less than eight months and are already undergoing IVF and preparing to move in together. Zoe earns around $160,000 a year, more than four times Sean’s $37,000 salary. But money is a constant source of tension, with Zoe revealing that 90–95% of their arguments are about finances.

Things get heated almost immediately when Ramit reads from Zoe’s application. As they dig into their spending, debt, and plans for a family, Sean opens up about the experiences that shaped his views on money, while Zoe explains why their financial conversations often turn into arguments. They work through significant changes to their spending plan, but can they find a way to talk about money and make decisions together?

A special thanks to our partners at Monarch for sponsoring this episode. Try Monarch free today and get 50% off your first year of Monarch Core at https://monarch.com/ramit, promo code RAMIT. Sign up through Ramit’s link to get his exact Conscious Spending Plan categories already set up in your account.

In this episode we uncover:

  • Why Zoe and Sean are already undergoing IVF after less than eight months together
  • How their initial spending plan puts fixed costs at 92% of their take-home income
  • How Zoe’s $160,000 income compares with Sean’s $37,000 salary, and why the gap creates tension
  • Why Zoe says 90–95% of their arguments are about money
  • How they disagree over whether Zoe can afford her current house
  • Why Zoe took out a $32,000 home equity line of credit to fund IVF
  • How a $44,000 loan from Zoe’s mother became an unexpected financial burden
  • How their different upbringings shaped their views on wealth, security, and being a provider
  • Why saving for a future baby raises difficult questions about responsibility for Sean’s existing debts
  • How their proposed financial changes could lower fixed costs from 92% to 56%, while deeper communication challenges remain

Chapters:

(00:00:00) Introduction

(00:02:55) The application that sparks an argument

(00:07:02) Selling the house, IVF, and marriage plans

(00:18:24) The four-times income gap and what it means to provide

(00:36:20) Unpacking their fixed costs and mounting debt

(00:53:39) How childhood experiences shape their relationship with money

(01:07:27) Reworking their spending plan to prepare for a family

(01:21:21) When money conversations turn into arguments

(01:30:07) A heated conversation with Ramit and an unresolved ending

(01:43:49) Follow-ups

 

💡 RAMIT’S PODCAST NEWSLETTER
• I share new ways to think about money every Saturday. Get the emails here: https://iwt.com/podcastnewsletter

🙌 GET HELP FROM RAMIT SETHI
• Order my new book: Money for Couples: https://iwt.com/moneyforcouples
• Take control of your money with the Conscious Spending Plan: https://iwt.com/csp
• Optimize your credit cards with the 1st chapter of my book: https://iwt.com/chapter1-pod
• Join my Rich Life: Road to $100K program: https://iwt.com/100k
• Listen to my book — now on Audible: https://amzn.to/48zko28

🤳 CONNECT WITH RAMIT SETHI
• Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ramit/
• X: https://twitter.com/ramit

✅ SUBSCRIBE SO YOU DON’T MISS ANY EPISODES
https://youtube.com/user/ramitsethi/featured/

This episode is brought to you by:



Leesa | Go to https://leesa.com for 30% off mattresses PLUS get an extra $50 off with promo code RAMIT, exclusive for my listeners

Zocdoc | Ready to be seen? Check that appointment off your to-do list with Zocdoc at https://zocdoc.com/ramit #sponsored

Gelt | Gelt is taking on new clients now. Find out if you qualify at https://joingelt.com/ramit

Wispr Flow | Try Wispr Flow for free at wisprflow.ai/ramit

If you and your partner are not completely aligned on money, I’m hosting a free event for you. I want you to use money to come together, not as something that keeps you apart. I’ll also be answering your questions live, so come to this event together. Sign up for free at iwt.com/live. 

Apply to be coached for free on this podcast at https://iwt.com/apply

 

Transcript:

[00:00:00] Ramit: You wrote, “He hates rich people, and I am one.”
[00:00:04] Zoe: Sean assumes that because I do make what I make, I shouldn’t have any financial challenges or stress. I can’t afford this house right now.
[00:00:13] Sean: I just think it’s, like, ridiculous. I would love to make that money.
[00:00:16] Ramit: She cannot afford her fixed costs. Do you spend more than you make every single month?
[00:00:20] So what’s the conclusion from all of this?
[00:00:22] Sean: That Zoe was right.
[00:00:24] Ramit: You’ve had several financial discussions. The housing one, IVF.
[00:00:28] Zoe: The biggest vision in my life is being a mom and having a kid, and, like, I wanna be able to have conversations where it feels like we’re building, but I’m not gonna give up my dreams to throw him a life preserver.
[00:00:41] Sean: Why would you let me struggle? I wouldn’t do that for you.
[00:00:43] Ramit: Isn’t she helping you out by paying more of the housing costs, by- Yeah.
[00:00:48] Sean: No, not yet … more of the proportion? Not yet,
[00:00:49] Ramit: because- Excuse me. I’ll finish talking on my own show. The two of you see money so profoundly differently. I think you have a serious problem What happens when one partner [00:01:00] earns four times as much as the other?
[00:01:03] Who pays for what? How do you plan for the future? And what happens when you disagree? Today, I’m talking to Zoe and Sean, 42 and 33 years old, who’ve been together for less than eight months. They’re preparing to move in together, and they’ve already started IVF. Before we meet them, let’s see what their Monarch account tells us.
[00:01:22] Whoa, fixed costs are 92%. Already, that’s too high. That means they’re spending more than they make every single month. Groceries at $1,605. Okay, lots of co-op spending. It’s almost every single day. Investments at $44,000. Okay, the mortgage is $285,000. A couple of student loans, a total of $70K, and then a loan from mom, $44K.
[00:01:43] These personal loans are killing me. Almost $6,000 in credit card collections. That is a huge red flag. Okay, looking at these numbers, I can already see some pretty serious financial challenges, but the numbers are only a little part of the story. The reason that I host this podcast is I want to go [00:02:00] deeper and hear what’s really going on.
[00:02:02] In fact, here, I want to understand whether Zoe and Sean have had these difficult financial conversations that they really should be having now. Before we begin, I want to ask you to keep an open mind. Today’s conversation gets heated, and at times it might be difficult to watch. But the way that we react to money is often shaped by experiences that are not immediately obvious.
[00:02:25] That doesn’t excuse how we treat others, but understanding where those reactions come from is an important part of making change. So as you watch, I encourage you to approach this conversation with curiosity rather than judgment. Stick around until the end, where we’ll hear from Zoe and Sean in their follow-up and find out whether they are making progress towards their rich life together.
[00:02:47] And now, let’s meet Zoe and Sean. Zoe, in your application, you wrote, “We can’t make any joint financial plans. I make almost four times as [00:03:00] much as he does, so he doesn’t feel comfortable telling me his true financial situation. I know vaguely where he is, and he knows where I am, but if I try to talk about certain things, it pulls us apart rather than bringing us together.”
[00:03:16] You then went on to say, “He hates rich people, and I am one.”
[00:03:22] Zoe: Yeah. Right.
[00:03:23] Sean: You said that, Zoe. Wow.
[00:03:24] Zoe: I did. Yeah, I did.
[00:03:26] Sean: Wow. And you’re not really rich, though.
[00:03:28] Ramit: But
[00:03:30] Sean: eventually, you probably will be
[00:03:32] Ramit: Zoe, do you still agree with the things you wrote?
[00:03:36] Zoe: Well, I wrote it about two months ago, and I think a lot has changed, um, in the course of, like, over the last two months.
[00:03:44] So I would say that we still have a lot of tension around money. We have more financial transparency, for sure. I think just getting ready for this podcast, we had to, like, open everything up and look at everything together. But I still definitely [00:04:00] feel like Sean exhibits animosity towards people that have money, and I think it’s just a function of, like, money is his sole source of anxiety.
[00:04:11] Um, and so I kinda understand where it comes from, but I definitely think that we have, 90 to 95% of the arguments that we have are rooted in something about money.
[00:04:21] Ramit: Sean, what’s your reaction to hearing that? Did you know that she wrote that? No. Mm-hmm. Did
[00:04:26] Sean: not.
[00:04:27] Ramit: Mm-hmm. And what’s your reaction hearing it?
[00:04:29] Sean: Kinda angry at her, actually. Little bit angry at you for that. I don’t hate rich people. That’s not true. Um, she was wrong about that. Mm. That was false. Um, I have a very wealthy extended family, and I hate entitled people. Let’s put it that way. I hate when people are entitled, ever.
[00:04:48] Ramit: What about the rest of what she wrote?
[00:04:49] We can’t make any joint financial plans. He doesn’t feel as comfortable telling me his true financial situation. If I try to talk about certain things, it pulls us apart rather than bringing us together.
[00:04:59] Sean: It’s [00:05:00] also false. We do talk about finances. We, we have been assimilating more in our relationship.
[00:05:06] Since May-ish, I’ve definitely divulged all of my financial, my, my debts and stuff to her. I mean, upon doing this Monarch stuff, too, which was awesome, by the way. It was really cool to see that all at once. But yeah, I mean, I don’t hate rich people. I know it’s come off like that sometimes. No, I just, I had to start from scratch four and a half years ago, so I, yeah, it’s-
[00:05:31] Ramit: Okay
[00:05:31] Sean: I don’t like hearing that from her.
[00:05:33] Ramit: Why?
[00:05:34] Sean: Because it’s like she aired out my dirty laundry to someone I don’t know.
[00:05:37] Ramit: Sean, we should get something straight right off the bat.
[00:05:40] Sean: What’s up?
[00:05:40] Ramit: This is the easiest thing we’re gonna talk about today. If the way you’re looking at this is she’s airing out your dirty laundry, we may not wanna continue the conversation.
[00:05:48] Okay. On the other hand, if you both want to have a better understanding of money, a better relationship with money together, then we’re gonna talk about a lot, and this is just the [00:06:00] smallest part of it.
[00:06:00] Zoe: I mean, I also think, I also wrote about, like, we have a great relationship that’s mostly great. Like, we love each other.
[00:06:07] We respect each other. Yeah. You know, like, there’s a lot good, I think, but, like, our major friction points are, are financial. Mm-hmm. And I think- Yeah … it’d be great to just talk about it and maybe, like, assume positive intent on both sides. This is not an adversarial thing. This is, like, a team thing.
[00:06:25] Ramit: Whoa. I was not expecting this, and I am taken aback by how ferocious his response to this comment on the application is.
[00:06:36] I think there is going to be a lot of resentment for me to have to unpack in this episode. Let’s see where it goes. How long have you two been together?
[00:06:45] Zoe: Little less than eight months maybe, right? Yeah. Yeah.
[00:06:49] Sean: January
[00:06:50] Zoe: something. January 1st, yeah.
[00:06:51] Ramit: Okay. And do you, do you live together?
[00:06:54] Zoe: We’re about to.
[00:06:55] Ramit: All right.
[00:06:55] And are you getting a new place or is one of you moving into the other’s?
[00:06:59] Zoe: We’re getting [00:07:00] a new place.
[00:07:01] Ramit: Yes. Cool. All right. Zoe, you filled out the application, some pretty vivid words in there. What is a time where you both really disagreed about money?
[00:07:12] Zoe: The first thing that comes to mind for me is me deciding to sell this house, and talking to Sean about it.
[00:07:19] Ramit: Take me there. What ha- Where were you, and what happened?
[00:07:24] Zoe: We actually were in the midst of filling out the conscious spending plans. Mm-hmm. And it was the weekend that we had decided to do that. And I think for me, just looking at my own numbers, I realized I need to downsize. And so I went to Sean, and I said, “Hey, you know, I’m thinking we should sell this house and get another place, because if we’re gonna move in together anyways, rather than you moving here and then us moving again in a few months, I think we should sort of find somewhere together.”
[00:07:56] And then Sean’s feelings around that [00:08:00] were, “I’m already making one change. I’m already planning to move. You can afford this current house. Like, I don’t wanna deal with one more variable right now.”
[00:08:10] Ramit: Can we go back to that time and actually just recreate the conversation? So Zoe, you said, “I think I should downsize,” et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
[00:08:19] And then Sean, as if you’re talking to her, what was your reaction?
[00:08:23] Sean: Don’t remember what I specifically said, but I know the intention was basically chill. Like, chill out for a little bit, wait until I get here, and then let’s move together. Let’s figure it out together, but it doesn’t have to be right now.
[00:08:36] You can pace yourself, and you can chill on it for a little bit. Like, it’s, it’s not imperative this second. But that wasn’t heard.
[00:08:45] Ramit: Zoe, what was your response?
[00:08:47] Zoe: Yeah, and then I think I said it, you know, “It makes no sense for you to move here and then move again in a couple of months. And also, I can’t afford this house right now.”
[00:08:58] And then I think [00:09:00] he said, like, “You can afford it.”
[00:09:01] Sean: Because you have, you, you have been. And you haven’t been struggling. So yeah, you can afford it.
[00:09:07] Ramit: And how do you know that, Sean, that she hasn’t been struggling?
[00:09:10] Sean: Because she’s, she lives like she’s not struggling.
[00:09:13] Ramit: How, how do you know that?
[00:09:14] Sean: Because I know how much she spends on things.
[00:09:18] And, like, I know that those are things that I wouldn’t pay for, for example, like I don’t need to survive. I can tell when someone’s struggling and when someone’s not. It takes one to know one. I’m not right now struggling. I’ve been working my way out of it.
[00:09:30] Ramit: Okay. Now, Zoe, this is your house, correct?
[00:09:33] Zoe: Mm-hmm.
[00:09:34] Ramit: And are the houses close by, or are we talking different cities?
[00:09:36] Sean: Far away, like an hour, hour and 10 minutes.
[00:09:39] Ramit: Okay. Zoe, out of curiosity, it’s your house, right? You can do whatever you want with it?
[00:09:44] Zoe: Yeah, that’s true. But we had a plan. The original plan was for him to move here into this house.
[00:09:50] Ramit: Okay.
[00:09:50] Zoe: And I wouldn’t just sell my house and buy a new house without having a conversation with him.
[00:09:56] Sean: You’re right. It’s her house, and, like, I don’t even have to really [00:10:00] be part of that. It’s like, if you want my input, it’s gonna be like, “No, you don’t need to do it right now.” But it is your house when it comes down to it. You’re gonna do what you want with your money. I appreciate you asking me. I real- I really do because I want to be a teammate, but you don’t have to.
[00:10:14] Ramit: Mm-hmm. Did you say that to her?
[00:10:15] Sean: I’m pretty sure I did at one point, and maybe it wasn’t with that specific thing, but I think it wa- I think it… I did say that to you.
[00:10:22] Ramit: Okay. When the plan was for Sean to move into your house, Zoe, had you discussed the financial arrangement?
[00:10:28] Zoe: Yeah, absolutely. We were talking about moving in together, and I sort of came to him and I said, like, “Hey, I have an idea of what I would want that to look like financially.”
[00:10:38] Ramit: What was
[00:10:38] Zoe: it? And I said, “The first month that you live here, I wouldn’t expect for you to pay anything, and then on subsequent months, I would expect you to pay $250. That would be less than what you’re spending now, so it would save you a little bit. But, like, um, also because we did the IVF, I will consider that, like, payments towards the IVF as [00:11:00] opposed to rent.”
[00:11:00] And then the other thing is when we started dating, um, I contribute, like, $120 to our, like, monthly dates and stuff. And I said, “And I’d also like you to contribute, like, $80 to that. So I’d like you to pay 250 for, like, rent and $80 for our couple stuff.”
[00:11:19] Ramit: Okay. And Sean, were you okay with that? Totally. Okay.
[00:11:22] Yeah, I mean, that’s more than fair. Let’s talk a little bit about the IVF. So you mentioned you did one cycle so far, correct?
[00:11:29] Zoe: Well, I’ve done two. I did one prior to meeting Sean- Mm-hmm … with donor sperm, and then we did one together.
[00:11:38] Ramit: Got it. And did you pay for that, Zoe?
[00:11:41] Zoe: Mm-hmm.
[00:11:42] Ramit: Got it. And did I understand correctly that you’re planning to do another round?
[00:11:46] Zoe: I think the current plan as it stands is for us to try to have two kids. We might try a couple rounds of IUI, but we’re not hopeful that that would work.
[00:11:55] Ramit: Got it. Okay, got it. And then is the intention to live [00:12:00] together or is the intention to also get married? Is, is that part of the conversation as well?
[00:12:05] Zoe: Yeah. For me, the baby thing, like, I have a ticking clock, and we gotta kind of figure that out and get on that. Yeah. As you know, I’m 42, about to be 43 in September, and, like, the biggest vision in my life is being a mom and having a kid, and, like, I was very clear about that when we met. Yeah. So that feels more expedient.
[00:12:23] I’d like to live together for maybe six months and then try to get pregnant, and then maybe next year he proposes, and maybe the year after or the year after that we get married.
[00:12:32] Ramit: So now that I think about it, you’ve had several complicated financial discussions: the housing one, IVF. Yeah. Wedding. Have you talked about the finances of a wedding as well?
[00:12:43] Zoe: Yeah. We
[00:12:44] Sean: have. We have.
[00:12:44] Ramit: Wow, look at that reaction. Sean, what happened in your discussion with Zoe about the money around a wedding?
[00:12:51] Sean: We tabled it, essentially.
[00:12:52] Ramit: We, we- What was the argument or the disagreement?
[00:12:54] Sean: I have a very large Irish family, and I want my people there, but-
[00:12:58] Zoe: And I said, “Well, yep, who’s [00:13:00] gonna, who’s gonna pay for that?”
[00:13:02] And he was … And he said, “Our families,” and I said, “I think, A, I- I would not assume that, so I think if we’re gonna believe that, then we need to go have conversations with our families about what they would contribute. And, B, I’m the least romantic person I know, so I would be fine with a $500 justice of the peace courthouse wedding, and if our families give us any money, we could put that towards some other future life goal.”
[00:13:26] Sean: Okay, so you tabled it.
[00:13:28] Zoe: We did. Yeah. I’m capable
[00:13:30] Sean: to. I’m capable to. And we’ll probably compromise somewhere in the middle though, honestly.
[00:13:34] Ramit: This isn’t just about Sean. The dynamic in a relationship never is only about one person. Notice that Zoe minimizes. She minimizes herself. She minimizes the conflict.
[00:13:45] She tries to placate him, because when she brings something up, he has a variety of conscious and unconscious techniques to shut it down, to make her feel bad, to make her think that what she’s saying doesn’t make any sense, when often it [00:14:00] does. So what does she do? She placates with the idea being that if I’m nice, if I’m polite, if I say it in this delicate way or don’t even bring it up at all, maybe he will come to see it my way.
[00:14:12] I’m gonna tell everybody point-blank, look deep in my eyes right now, that never works. That is not how it works. When you placate someone, you do not bring them over to your side. There’s only two ways to do this. Number one, set a big, bold vision of what you expect and what you want to achieve, and maybe they will achieve it, maybe not.
[00:14:32] Number two, if that big, bold vision and expectation is not met, you leave. Those are the only two ways that it works when somebody is not willing to even listen. So let’s just remember, this is not just about Sean. Zoe plays a very big part as well. I have a date night idea for you. If you and your partner are not completely, totally, inextricably aligned on money, [00:15:00] I’m gonna host a free event for you.
[00:15:02] I want you to be able to use money as a way to come together, not as something that keeps you apart. I want you to know exactly what your shared rich life is. I’m gonna show you how to figure out what your individual rich lives are, and I’m gonna help you figure out how to simplify your money so you know when you can take that vacation, so you know if one of you wants to stop working, when that can happen.
[00:15:23] I’m also gonna answer your questions live, so come to this event together and let’s do this. You can sign up for free at iwt.com/live. It’s interesting that when I talk to people about what they like to spend money on, many of them will talk about their health, their wellness. Then I look on their bed, it’s sinking like the Titanic, huge just big old V in the middle of their mattress.
[00:15:47] I go, “You never bought a new mattress? Do you have any back pain?” They go, “Yeah, of course, but that’s normal.” No, it’s not. If that’s you, it may be time to treat yourself this holiday season and replace your old mattress with something that’s actually supportive and [00:16:00] comfortable, like a mattress from Leesa. I chose to buy a Leesa mattress, and every night I love it.
[00:16:06] Leesa has a lineup of premium, beautifully crafted mattresses designed specifically for how you sleep, whether it’s on your stomach, side, or back. They use eco-friendly materials like their new Green Flex Foam made from USDA certified renewable plant-based materials that cool you as you sleep and stay sag-free for years.
[00:16:26] If you’re not sure which mattress is the right fit, Leesa is now offering free concierge calls with real sleep specialists to help make choosing a mattress easy. Book a one-on-one 15-minute appointment today to find your perfect match. Every Leesa mattress comes with free shipping, easy returns, and a 365-night sleep trial.
[00:16:45] Go to leesa.com for 30% off select mattresses, plus get an extra $50 off with promo code Ramit exclusive for my listeners. That’s L-E-E-S-A.com, promo code Ramit for 30% off select [00:17:00] mattresses plus an extra $50 off. Let them know we sent you in the survey after checkout. Leesa.com, promo code Ramit. When IWT first started growing over 20 years ago, the first person I hired was an assistant, and I am so glad that I made that decision.
[00:17:18] I personally love not having to deal with booking flights or calling doctor’s offices. But you don’t need to have an assistant to avoid playing phone tag with your dentist. You can just book your next appointment using Zocdoc, this episode’s sponsor, and have it handled without ever picking up the phone.
[00:17:33] Zocdoc lets you search and compare local in-network doctors. Whether you’re looking for primary care, dentistry, eye care, or anything else, you can easily search by specialty or symptom and book in-network appointments with more than 150,000 providers across all 50 states. Getting an actual appointment is easy.
[00:17:52] Just look through real appointment openings, click what works for your schedule, and book it instantly. Their appointments happen fast, [00:18:00] usually within 24 to 72 hours, so no more waiting months to get the care that you need. Your health matters, and taking care of yourself should not be complicated.
[00:18:09] Sean: Ready to be seen?
[00:18:10] Ramit: Head to zocdoc.com/ramit to get started and check that appointment off your to-do list. That’s Z-O-C-D-O-C.com/ramit.
[00:18:24] I wanna take a look at your numbers. Mm-hmm. What was it like to do the conscious spending plan together?
[00:18:28] Zoe: I thought it was awesome. I thought it was really sort of fun. I thought it illuminated a lot of things. It took way longer than the allotted hour and a half because like in the middle of it, I decided I need to sell my house, and then we, like, went and looked at places that weekend.
[00:18:47] Um, but I thought that it was, like, very helpful and constructive and a really great way to have conversations, like, with specificity. Great. And so I liked it a lot. Great.
[00:18:59] Ramit: Sean, what about you? [00:19:00]
[00:19:00] Sean: Same thing. It was nice to break down a lot of my expenses, too. And I mean, it, it was, it was good to, to lay it out in front of me.
[00:19:07] Ramit: Great. Let’s take a look at the numbers. All right. Zoe, can you read off the word in bold and then the number next to it for this entire box, please?
[00:19:17] Zoe: Assets, $398,032. Investments, $41,400. Savings, $17,320. Debt, $414,831, and $41,921.
[00:19:34] Ramit: So your total net worth is $41,921. Okay. What do you think about those numbers?
[00:19:40] Zoe: Well, because I know what those numbers represent, I’m actually really excited about them.
[00:19:45] Ramit: Mm-hmm.
[00:19:46] Zoe: Yeah, I feel, like, optimistic, excited.
[00:19:49] Ramit: Great. Sean, what do you, what do you feel about the numbers?
[00:19:52] Sean: Um, I, I don’t know. Numbers are objective. I don’t really…
[00:19:57] Ramit: Do you understand them?
[00:19:59] Sean: Yeah, of course. [00:20:00] Yes, I do. Okay.
[00:20:00] Ramit: All right.
[00:20:01] Let’s go down to the income. Sean, if you can read off the combined gross monthly income, please.
[00:20:10] Sean: Uh, $14,973.
[00:20:14] Ramit: Okay, great. So that’s a very good income. So together the two of you make $179,676 per year. By show of hands, who knew that?
[00:20:26] Zoe: Well-
[00:20:28] Sean: So
[00:20:28] Ramit: it’s either hands up or hands down. It’s one or the other.
[00:20:31] Sean: I knew it was less than 200,000, but I knew it was over 170.
[00:20:34] Ramit: So- That’s a… What? That’s a no. That, no. That doesn’t count either. That’s a no. And Zoe-
[00:20:39] Zoe: Fine. Well, I know my floor always, but I don’t know my ceiling because there are some variables in my, in my income, like bonuses, commissions, those kinds of things. So I knew his number, but I estimated lower.
[00:20:55] Ramit: That’s a good decision in general.
[00:20:57] Zoe: Yeah.
[00:20:58] Sean: Yes. Do,
[00:20:58] Ramit: do you all feel like [00:21:00] when you talk about money it’s, like, very confusing? Like, do you feel like you don’t get a straight answer with each other?
[00:21:06] Sean: Yes.
[00:21:07] Ramit: I feel that right now.
[00:21:09] Sean: Yeah.
[00:21:09] Ramit: Thank
[00:21:09] Sean: you.
[00:21:10] Ramit: Like, even asking simple questions to each of you. Yes or no, did you know this number? No. It’s okay to say no or yeah, or like, “This or that.
[00:21:17] I want this. I don’t want that. We got in a fight. No, we didn’t get in a fight.” This has happened now multiple times- Mm-hmm … where I’m trying to ask a question, and I’m wondering if I’m getting mixed answers, and I know this stuff very well, then are the two of you getting mixed answers and confusing answers when you talk about money?
[00:21:37] Sean was nodding his head furiously yes. Yeah. Yeah. No, Sean is saying yes. Are you feeling that way, Zoe? It’s confusing?
[00:21:43] Zoe: Yeah, definitely.
[00:21:45] Sean: Let me amend that though really quickly. I’m not confused by numbers. I’m really good at numbers, honestly. But, uh, it’s the communication with us associating with numbers, partly my fault because of I don’t wanna really talk about it until I’m in a better position, but that’s [00:22:00] just me.
[00:22:01] But I agree with you.
[00:22:02] Ramit: Sean, you just confused me with your answer. Yeah, I did. You gave me two negatives in that answer. You said, “I feel this way, but actually not that way, but actually not that way.” Do you hear yourself?
[00:22:13] Sean: Yeah, I did. I did.
[00:22:14] Ramit: Why are you doing that? ‘
[00:22:15] Sean: Cause I want, I wanna be understood. I wanna qualify, I guess.
[00:22:18] I don’t know.
[00:22:18] Ramit: I don’t want qualifications. I’m not interested. And actually it’s, it’s doing both of you a disservice because if we wanna get where we wanna go today, it’s okay to just say, like, “I don’t know what that means.” There’s no shame in that. It’s okay to say, “I didn’t know that number,” or, “I approximated it.
[00:22:35] I could be wrong, but yes, that’s what I did.” This isn’t just for me. It’s actually for you because if you can’t be direct with yourself, then you can’t be direct with your partner. If you can’t be direct with your partner, then you can’t talk about money.
[00:22:47] Zoe: I’ll say I feel a level of insecurity around how much money I make and talking about that.
[00:22:54] Ramit: Hold on. Let’s put this on screen ’cause I wanna make sure I understand. Okay, so you make $12,000 a month. Yes. So [00:23:00] $144,000 a year. You feel insecure about that because it’s too, too high.
[00:23:05] Zoe: Mm-hmm. Okay. And I estimated low, so I probably make 160.
[00:23:10] Ramit: 160. Okay.
[00:23:11] Zoe: Yeah.
[00:23:12] Ramit: Got it.
[00:23:12] Sean: Wow. W- wow, why? Because I don’t know, I feel like she does things conservative to, like, be nice to me or something.
[00:23:20] Um, and it’s, it’s annoying. And honestly, like, that’s why you’re not struggling. Obviously
[00:23:28] Ramit: Who said she’s struggling? I never heard her say that.
[00:23:30] Sean: No, I know, but I did earlier in my conversation. I-
[00:23:33] Ramit: Zoe, I think I heard you say you couldn’t afford your housing. Is that correct? Yes. I think there’s a difference between I can’t afford the place I live versus I am struggling.
[00:23:42] Do you see it that way, Sean?
[00:23:43] Sean: No, I think they’re synonymous.
[00:23:45] Ramit: They’re syn- Okay.
[00:23:46] Sean: All right. Because I’ve, I’ve been there before. I’ve had to choose between food and rent at one point in my life.
[00:23:50] Ramit: Got it. Okay. Not
[00:23:51] Sean: many people have been there, have they? So it’s like, yeah. Yeah.
[00:23:55] Ramit: Okay.
[00:23:56] Sean: That’s why.
[00:23:57] Ramit: Let’s continue working down the CSP, and we’ll take a look at what [00:24:00] it all means.
[00:24:00] Sean, you currently make $2,920 a month, or annually you make $35,000 a year. Did you know that?
[00:24:08] Sean: That’s conservative, but yes.
[00:24:10] Ramit: Another mixed answer. What is the actual number? That’s what I wanna know.
[00:24:13] Sean: Like 38, 37.
[00:24:16] Ramit: 37,000? Okay, so we have a disparity in income, one making 37,000, the other making 160,000. So Zoe, you mentioned you were insecure because of how high your income is.
[00:24:29] Can you tell, explain that to me?
[00:24:31] Zoe: So I feel insecure not just with Sean, but in general, speaking with people who maybe make less than I do and have assumptions around that. But I think in a relationship, it’s definitely magnified.
[00:24:47] Ramit: Why?
[00:24:47] Zoe: Because I think Sean assumes that because I do make what I make, I shouldn’t have any financial challenges or stress or pressure.
[00:24:56] For example, I’m gonna get a bonus with work, [00:25:00] and I think he is both happy for me, and it also brings up his own feelings of insecurity, and so it, it could go in either direction. So I think I sort of try to downplay that part of my life.
[00:25:13] Ramit: Mm-hmm. How do you do that? Give me an example.
[00:25:15] Zoe: When we filled out the CSP, I filled it out based on my base salary.
[00:25:18] I didn’t include bonuses or commissions because those are variable, and I didn’t wanna have a conversation about that. Like, um, because A, it’s hard to predict, and B, I feel like it leads to more of a feeling of disparity.
[00:25:35] Ramit: Thank you. That is honest. I really appreciate you saying that because I can tell that y- you’re, you’re pretty conversant with numbers.
[00:25:43] For somebody who goes through the CSP process and realizes they can’t afford their housing, they have a skill with numbers. Sean, what’s your reaction to hearing that?
[00:25:53] Sean: I, I appreciate the honesty.
[00:25:55] Ramit: Yeah. Can I ask a question, Zoe? If the roles were reversed and Sean were earning [00:26:00] 160K and you were earning $37,000 a year, do you think the dynamics would be the same?
[00:26:06] Zoe: Been in those relationships, and it’s different. It’s, uh… No, I don’t think it would be the same at all.
[00:26:11] Ramit: What happened in those relationships, financially speaking? What was it like when he was earning more?
[00:26:16] Zoe: I think that’s just the expectation, so it was not even really a matter of consideration. Like, we didn’t think about it.
[00:26:24] I think it’s way more amplified because of our genders and maybe our ages.
[00:26:30] Ramit: Yeah. The idea that a man making more, that it would be this topic that he would have to walk on eggshells around is just inconceivable to most. What do you mean? What, what’s the problem? Right. Most people wouldn’t even know, what are we talking about here?
[00:26:45] But we flip the genders, and there are very real differences in expectation, et cetera. The approach that I see is Zoe, you minimize it. You don’t talk about it. You are conservative in your estimates. Sean, when [00:27:00] she does bring it up, you are confused about why is she talking about I, I, I can’t afford this living situation.
[00:27:08] She’s not struggling. She makes 140, 150, 160K, and that seems to be the way that the two of you have dealt with it. Am I reading that correctly?
[00:27:17] Sean: No, I’m not confused about it. That’s the wrong choice of words. I’m annoyed by it. I don’t wanna address it because I am traditionalist generally. I mean, I’ve been brought up that way.
[00:27:28] The man should make more. But I’m kinda starting out again, so I’m at the bottom. But then I met a, a woman I love, so it’s just like here we are, right?
[00:27:36] Ramit: Sean, what if you go through the rest of your relationship and you never earn more than Zoe?
[00:27:41] Sean: And that’s something I can accept, honestly.
[00:27:43] Ramit: Great.
[00:27:44] Sean: And I’ve thought about that.
[00:27:45] I have. Absolutely. Mm-hmm. I’ve thought about that. As long as, like, I’m not slaving 60, 60 hours a week and breaking myself- Mm-hmm … to still make less. Seriously.
[00:27:56] Ramit: So if Zoe continues making 160, [00:28:00] 180, 220, whatever the number may end up being-
[00:28:02] Sean: That’d be great.
[00:28:03] Ramit: You’re happy with that?
[00:28:04] Sean: I would love that, yeah. Great.
[00:28:06] Absolutely.
[00:28:07] Ramit: Okay. So out of curiosity then, just to take it to the next logical step, Zoe, if Sean is happy for how much you earn, number one, do you believe that? And number two, if so, why do you minimize your earnings?
[00:28:18] Zoe: Think he will be happy for me when he’s earning more. I think it’s hard for him now because money is an area of stress for him.
[00:28:29] I think he wants to be happy for me, and I think he tries to be happy for me, but I think it just amplifies his own stresses and anxieties about money, and so that comes up to the surface. But I think when he is making more money, it will be less of a issue.
[00:28:46] Ramit: How much does he need to make in order to feel happy for you?
[00:28:49] Zoe: I feel like 50 to 60,000, and to not be struggling as much, I think he would feel like he had more breathing room.
[00:28:57] Ramit: Okay. Sean, what’s your take?
[00:28:59] Sean: I wanna- [00:29:00] I don’t wanna make 60. I don’t. I wanna make $100,000 a year. I mean, unfortunately, I wanna make up for lost time. I have a drive, I just don’t have the opportunity yet.
[00:29:10] Um, I don’t need to make more money than her, but I do wanna be the provider. I wanna protect my family. I wanna, like, do what I’ve been grown up to. What’s a provider? Protector and, uh, someone who can pay for most of the stuff. The guy that will go out in the middle of the night because my girlfriend hears a noise and, like, I don’t know, I just wanna feel like I’m valuable to her.
[00:29:36] Ramit: All right. Going back to the provider thing, my question was, what is a provider? Tell me more. You said, “I’d like to be able to buy most things.” Candidly, in this relationship, that’s not gonna be the case. That’s fine. If she makes way more, she’s gonna be buying more things. That’s how it’s gonna be. Do you accept that?
[00:29:51] Sean: Yeah. I mean, as long as she shares it with me, really. If we’re together, that’s what it is. If we’re a team- Yeah … then, yeah.
[00:29:58] Ramit: Okay. So what is a provider if you’re not [00:30:00] buying most things?
[00:30:01] Sean: Someone who my family looks up to, and- L- asks for advice, looks for protection, trusts, provides. Well, I, I think about security.
[00:30:12] Number one for me is security.
[00:30:14] Ramit: What– Security means what?
[00:30:15] Sean: Stable, solid ground, anti-anxiety, if you will. Um-
[00:30:19] Ramit: Mm-hmm …
[00:30:20] Sean: I wanna be that source of relief and stability for my family and people. I’ve been brought up to think that’s money. Money is king, you know? And from my, whatever, from my own choices, um, where I’m at now.
[00:30:36] Ramit: First of all, every man that I’ve talked to about this topic says his role is to be the provider. Yeah. 100% of men, okay? It’s not written in any book. It’s not in some guidebook that we all got when we were born. It just is in the social fabric of many countries. Next, when I ask them, “What is a provider?”
[00:30:57] many of them say, “Money. I need to be the [00:31:00] breadwinner.” We have these phrases, right? And then often I’ll talk to a, a couple where the woman earns substantially more than the man, like in this relationship. I say, “Well, look, you’re not gonna earn more than she does. So if you are not earning more, what is a provider?”
[00:31:14] And they are stumped, just as what happened here. But I like your answers. I like that you said providing security.
[00:31:22] Sean: Yeah.
[00:31:23] Ramit: And I said, like, “What is that?” ‘Cause again, that’s just a word. But you said providing stability, providing calm. I really like those phrases. I like ’em a lot. Can you be a provider if you earn, I don’t know, a tenth as much as your female partner?
[00:31:39] Sean: Based on my definition I just gave you, yes.
[00:31:41] Ramit: I love it. I agree.
[00:31:43] Sean: Oh, yeah.
[00:31:43] Ramit: Because guess what? You can be a provider if you make $0 in my book. Stay-at-home dads, providers. Money’s just one way to provide. Why do we overvalue it so much? It’s actually not that hard. If we wanna make it, there’s plenty of opportunities.
[00:31:58] There’s lots of ways to do it. [00:32:00] There’s also choices we make where we say, “Look, I’m deciding for this season of life, I’m a stay-at-home dad,” or, “I got injured, and I can’t work.” You can still provide for your family. There’s so many ways to do it. You know, I like money a lot, but I dislike the power that it holds over people.
[00:32:16] Sean: Me too
[00:32:17] Ramit: Why are Zoe and Sean trapped in a cage of social expectations? Sean has to be the big, bad provider because he’s a man. And then what does Zoe have to do? Oh, she’s gotta be the placater. Even though Zoe earns multiple times more income than he does, she has to go, “I don’t know. I’m not sure. What do you think?
[00:32:36] I could be wrong.” You’re not wrong. Don’t just look at them and point fingers at them. We are all trapped in this game, all of us. Think about the expectations that you have. Just who takes out the trash in your household? Who feeds the kids? Think about it. You didn’t just wake up one day and go, “That’s what I need,” which just happens to correspond with what 300 million other Americans do.[00:33:00]
[00:33:00] We are social creatures. I don’t mind it, okay? What I do mind is you not examining these expectations. Do you need to be the provider as a man? Maybe, maybe not. Do you need to be delicate and placate your partner if you are a very successful woman? What if instead you set a big old expectation? “I’ve worked hard.
[00:33:22] I’m fortunate. Here are my expectations in this partnership. I don’t expect you to know investments like I do, but I expect you to be able to be conversant with money. Tell me your plan. Let’s get there together.” Zoe and Sean, I hope you hear this. You can challenge these expectations and rewrite them for your own relationship.
[00:33:40] I have a lot of friends who are entrepreneurs, a lot of friends who are not entrepreneurs, and one difference between the two is that the friends who run businesses basically have to be proactive at work all the time. They cannot wait for something to happen or a boss to tell them what to do. So you’ll find that they’re kind of constantly looking around corners trying to figure out what’s next so [00:34:00] they can make plans.
[00:34:01] And I have found that being proactive is a skill. If you wanna be proactive with next year’s taxes, I recommend checking out this episode’s sponsor, Gelt. Gelt is a modern CPA firm that helps your business take control of your tax strategy year-round. By working with Gelt, you get access to one dedicated tax strategist with real human expertise, powered by cutting edge technology that handles the rest.
[00:34:25] They help with more than just your tax forms. They can make strategic adjustments to things like how you pay yourself, your retirement plan set up, even how you structure your business tax system. And right now in Q4, they can help you run a calculated projection so you know exactly where you’ll land this year while you still have time to make changes.
[00:34:43] Gelt is taking on new clients before the year is over. The smartest tax move you can make is not waiting until next year to get started. So start your year-end review at joingelt.com/ramit. If something saves me [00:35:00] time and I can throw money at the problem, I love it, and I found that my team is the same way.
[00:35:05] That is why so many of us are using this episode’s sponsor, Whisperflow. Whisperflow turns the way you naturally talk into clean, ready to send text in any app on any device. And I’m talking about Slack, Gmail, Notion, iMessage, ChatGPT, Claude, Mac, Windows, Android, all of it. With Whisperflow, you can just hit a hotkey, speak, and the text appears accurately, perfectly formatted, and it’s way faster than typing it.
[00:35:35] My team and I use it every day, and we love it. Plus it’s smart, so you’re not sending a block of incoherent text. Unlike other dictation apps, it corrects mistakes, it gets names right, and it can format bullet points and lists on the fly. Personally, I love that. Sometimes I’m just walking, I dictate a bunch of ideas, and they come out formatted with the bullet points included.
[00:35:58] If you like talking instead of [00:36:00] texting and typing, this is a no-brainer. Get one month of WhisperFlow Pro for free at whisperflow.ai/ramit. That’s whisperflow.ai/ramit, W-I-S-P-R flow.a-i/ramit, or click the link in the description Are you familiar with the numbers on the conscious spending plan, the ones you put in?
[00:36:24] Sean: Oh, yeah.
[00:36:25] Ramit: Okay, great. Then I’m gonna ask you questions about it. Tell me the fixed cost number that you see here.
[00:36:29] Sean: Oh, ninety-two percent.
[00:36:30] Ramit: What does that tell you?
[00:36:31] Sean: We have a surplus of eight percent every month, and that’s it.
[00:36:35] Ramit: Yes. It tells me that you spend more than you make every month. Now look at the two numbers here.
[00:36:40] Your number for fixed costs is what?
[00:36:42] Sean: One ten.
[00:36:43] Ramit: One hundred ten percent. What does that tell you?
[00:36:45] Sean: That I am living above my means.
[00:36:47] Ramit: Yes. You spend more than you make every single month just on fixed costs. Now, what about Zoe’s number?
[00:36:53] Sean: Eighty-seven percent.
[00:36:54] Ramit: What does that tell you?
[00:36:56] Sean: That she is close, but within her [00:37:00] means.
[00:37:00] Ramit: Maybe, maybe not.
[00:37:01] Sean: I don’t know, actually. I don’t know.
[00:37:03] Ramit: Okay, that’s good. That’s the first time I’ve heard you say, “I don’t know.”
[00:37:07] Sean: Thank you for recognizing that.
[00:37:08] Ramit: Do you know what this number is supposed to be?
[00:37:10] Sean: No.
[00:37:11] Ramit: Okay. It’s supposed to be below sixty percent. Fifty to sixty is the target. So if the number is supposed to be, let’s just say, sixty, and Zoe’s is eighty-seven, what does that tell you?
[00:37:23] Sean: That there’s definitely room for improvement.
[00:37:27] Ramit: Yeah. Or to put it more plainly, she cannot afford her fixed costs. If we look at her fixed costs to go below them, look at all the numbers in her fixed cost column. What’s the biggest one?
[00:37:37] Sean: Mortgage.
[00:37:38] Ramit: Yeah. So what’s the conclusion from all of this?
[00:37:41] Sean: That Zoe was right, that she should downsize.
[00:37:45] Ramit: Yeah, that she cannot afford her house.
[00:37:48] Sean: Okay. If the mortgage payment is four hundred dollars less, it’s not gonna change. It’s not gonna get to that fifty to sixty percent.
[00:37:56] Ramit: That’s, that’s a separate issue. She, during the CSP, discovered [00:38:00] that her housing is too expensive. She’s at eighty-seven percent. That’s way, way, way too high.
[00:38:06] So her conclusion was, gotta downsize. But your response to that was what?
[00:38:12] Sean: Not right now.
[00:38:13] Ramit: That’s true. And what was the other thing?
[00:38:15] Sean: You can afford it.
[00:38:16] Ramit: Yeah. You can afford it because I don’t see you struggling. But here it’s clear just from the math that she cannot afford it. What, what’s your take on this?
[00:38:24] It’s a pretty interesting realization here. What’s your take?
[00:38:28] Sean: I believe it’s all relative, and that she still can afford it, and that she could trim other things. ‘Cause that surplus is probably what I make a month anyway. Once you struggle, you learn to be able to, like, live with less and downsize and whatever.
[00:38:43] I mean, okay, I think it would make her more comfortable, for sure, but I don’t think it’s gonna make a huge dent if it’s a few hundred dollars less a month.
[00:38:51] Ramit: Zoe, what’s your take on Sean’s response just now?
[00:38:54] Zoe: Yeah, I, I feel a little sad. I think there’s so much [00:39:00] more that we can accomplish both individually and together if we don’t settle, and it just kind of makes me sad too.
[00:39:08] Like, I, I want you to have as little stress as possible, and so, like, I would want you to want the same thing for me.
[00:39:15] Sean: I do. I do. And I’m not saying– I’m just saying, like- When it comes down to it objectively, yes, you can still afford it, but I understand it would make it easier, and it’s a great starting off point with us for a new house.
[00:39:29] I am not against it. I really do feel good, and I love the house too. But, like, if you needed to stay here, you absolutely could.
[00:39:39] Ramit: Let’s keep going through the numbers. The debt, $414,831. What is this debt made up of?
[00:39:46] Zoe: So it’s my mortgage. I took out a home equity line of credit to do the second round of IVF.
[00:39:54] Ramit: Mm-hmm.
[00:39:54] Zoe: The HELOC is $32,000 and some change. The mortgage [00:40:00] is $286,000.
[00:40:02] Ramit: Okay.
[00:40:03] Zoe: At the time of the CSP, I owed $2,300 on a credit card, but I only owe $1,000 now.
[00:40:11] Ramit: Okay.
[00:40:11] Zoe: And that’s it for my side of things.
[00:40:14] Ramit: What do you got, Sean?
[00:40:15] Sean: So I don’t have Monarch up in front of me right now, but I definitely owe the IRS some money.
[00:40:21] I would say $8,000. I’ve had multiple credit cards go into collections.
[00:40:26] Ramit: Total amount?
[00:40:27] Sean: $8,900 overall for that. I have student loans.
[00:40:31] Ramit: How much?
[00:40:32] Sean: $34,000.
[00:40:33] Ramit: Okay. What else?
[00:40:34] Sean: I think that might be it, actually.
[00:40:37] Ramit: Why the credit card collections? That’s a big red flag.
[00:40:42] Sean: I know. Oh, it is.
[00:40:44] Ramit: Why?
[00:40:44] Sean: Because I’m an alcoholic in recovery.
[00:40:47] I, I mean I’m nearly five years clean and sober, but that’s why. Got it. Yeah. Got it. I’ve been in recovery for a while. It’s– That’s why the late restart. I’m [00:41:00] thirty-three years old. I restarted at twenty-eight. What happened? A lot. I mean, I don’t know how to… I got a DUI the la- the last thing before I finally decided to give up in late twenty twenty-one, and after that I, I wanted to die.
[00:41:17] I really did, but I couldn’t do it myself. It was a really terrible time for me. So I went to rehab, and it was the best, hardest decision and best thing I’ve ever done. But yeah, new state, didn’t come here with an ID or a license. Two years in, I was struggling too, really badly. Really badly. And, uh, my best friend asked me if I wanna start working as an electrician.
[00:41:42] Complete career, career change, and I’ve been doing it ever since. So I started at the bottom again, and then here we are, so. But that’s what it is, man. I mean, it wasn’t just alcohol, but you can fill in the blanks there. I went down a bad path, and I’ve been really trying to fix it, and it’s been a real, real grind, but [00:42:00] it’s been worth it.
[00:42:01] It’s been really worth it, but it’s hard.
[00:42:03] Ramit: I appreciate you sharing that. I really do. And five years, congratulations. That’s- Thank
[00:42:09] Sean: you, man …
[00:42:09] Ramit: impressive. Life-changing.
[00:42:12] Sean: Yeah.
[00:42:12] Ramit: Yeah. Well done. Well done. Thank you. That’s really good.
[00:42:15] Sean: Appreciate it.
[00:42:16] Ramit: Zoe, you met Sean a little less than a year ago, so you must have heard about his journey- Mm
[00:42:23] I’m assuming pretty early on.
[00:42:25] Zoe: Oh, yeah, for sure, like, before we even met. I’m in recovery from anorexia and bulimia myself, so I moved to where I currently live for treatment, like, sixteen years ago. And so I think, like, I really admire that in Sean and respect his recovery and feel like he’s, like, very empathetic and understanding about my own like- Mm-hmm
[00:42:48] journey, uh, which is a little bit different than drugs and alcohol because, like, I have to have a relationship with the thing that I have a problem with, and I have nothing but admiration for him and empathy. I also really [00:43:00] appreciate his emotional intelligence and his openness and his vulnerability, and I think, like, that’s something, like, really rare.
[00:43:06] I mean, you asked about providers earlier, and, like, for me, like, on the emotional level and the spiritual level and the mental stimulation level, like, I feel like Sean is such a provider, you know? So-
[00:43:17] Sean: Yeah …
[00:43:17] Zoe: yeah.
[00:43:19] Sean: And Lynn, can I just add something to that too? Yeah. We have a great relationship, but the only really thing, bad thing is money.
[00:43:26] I mean, it’s difficult for, for us because of our discrepancy and because of like, you know, social expectations and stigmas and stuff, and how I went to an all an all-boys military and religious academy, and we were taught to be the man, make more money, and provide and, and that kind of stuff. I don’t really subscribe to that.
[00:43:46] Ramit: Yeah.
[00:43:46] Sean: But this is the first time I’ve been faced with this whole thing, and that’s the only point of contention in our relationship.
[00:43:51] Ramit: I appreciate that. It’s interesting that I hear that a lot. I hope that provides actually some comfort, because sometimes it can feel like, oh [00:44:00] God, like are we the only ones?
[00:44:01] But you cannot estimate the number of couples I’ve talked to who say, “We have a very loving relationship. We are in flow. We anticipate each other’s needs. But it’s this one thing, money, where we get in fights. We disagree. We just can’t talk about it.” So to me, when I look at money, I don’t just see numbers on a page.
[00:44:22] I don’t just see gender expectations, although I know they are very real. I see possibilities. I see where can we live? What can we do? How can we be secure? I see fun. I see freedom to be able to go to the grocery store and maybe buy something and not have to look at the price. I see money actually bringing a couple together, like I do with my wife, not keeping us apart.
[00:44:49] Now, sure, we disagree about stuff. That’s okay. That’s natural. That’s what happens with every couple. But ultimately, having this thing, this north star of a rich life, and then using our [00:45:00] money, time, energy, love to get there That to me is the whole point. So that’s what I see. When I’m looking at this, I’m trying to understand the mechanics on the page, but more importantly, there’s some meaning behind it I’m trying to get to.
[00:45:12] Sean: Yeah.
[00:45:13] Ramit: Zoe, you mentioned anorexia and bulimia. Congratulations on your recovery as well. Thanks. Thank you for sharing that as well. And like you said, yeah, particularly challenging because you have to have a relationship with food every day.
[00:45:25] Sean: Right.
[00:45:26] Ramit: So-
[00:45:26] Sean: Yeah.
[00:45:26] Ramit: Yeah.
[00:45:26] Zoe: Interestingly, though, like, your podcast, there’s a lot of similarities between food and money and eating.
[00:45:33] So, like, sometimes I extrapolate, and it’s, yeah, it’s been helpful with the eating disorder stuff as well.
[00:45:39] Ramit: Oh, I’m so happy to hear that. You are right that I have noticed so many similarities on my own fitness journey. Okay. In fact, I write about them in the introduction of my book. But I’m so happy that you adapted them, and you’ve found them to be sensitive to the situation that you require.
[00:45:56] Yeah, totally. That’s awesome. Yeah. Thank you. That’s really nice to hear. I did not know [00:46:00] that. Let’s continue going down the fixed costs. Okay? Sure. I have more questions, and then I wanna start looking at some more of these numbers. Okay, so we’re at 92% fixed costs, which just means you are spending more than you make every single month.
[00:46:12] This is a massive problem. Mm-hmm. Now, I wanna acknowledge that Zoe, you probably have an extra 20K coming in through bonuses, and that will change things significantly. If we just wanna take a look at what it might do, I’ll just kind of back of the napkin here, I’m gonna add instead of 10,632, I’m gonna make it 12,632, so we can see what happens.
[00:46:33] It drops your fixed cost significantly to 77%, but it’s still too high. So I’m gonna take that off for now. We have a mortgage that is 21%, which on a notes, on its own is not huge. But then we have some other expenses. We have insurance at $1,321 a month, car payment 476, no problem there, debt payment 864, groceries at 1,594.
[00:46:59] Zoe: That’s mostly [00:47:00] me.
[00:47:00] Ramit: What, what, what is it going to, Zoe? Is it, like, a particular type of food or what?
[00:47:04] Zoe: When I’m eating myself, I mostly just get, like, pre-prepared stuff. I don’t spend a whole lot of time in the kitchen when it’s just me by myself.
[00:47:13] Ramit: Subscriptions are at 252. Yeah, that’s a little high, but that’s not the real problem here.
[00:47:18] And then miscellaneous at 1,270. I believe it, actually. We’re gonna look at some of your spending. But even if we bring that number down to 300, you’re still at 82%. We have some structural problems here. Investments are at 12%. Is this true you’re putting 1250 post-tax, Zoe? All right. And then savings are at $250 a month and your total savings are at $17,000, so you have about two months of fixed costs.
[00:47:44] What do you think about that?
[00:47:45] Zoe: Well, I’m not worried about it ’cause I have a three-month severance package built into my work, so if they let me go for any reason, I would get three months.
[00:47:54] Ramit: Okay.
[00:47:55] Zoe: Yeah.
[00:47:55] Ramit: That’s good to know. And then you’re down here, obviously it’s negative 7%, which is not real. No, it’s- So [00:48:00] it can’t be.
[00:48:00] Then so that is likely going into- Yeah … more debt. Let’s go into Monarch. So let’s take a look at your debts here. So if you look at the loans, I see a mortgage. Mm-hmm. I see this one. What’s this loan from mom, $44,000?
[00:48:15] Zoe: That is one of the reasons I’m selling my house. My mom gave me a loan that she said, “Don’t worry about paying me back.”
[00:48:23] And then she said she wanted it back, so I bought a house that was more expensive than I would have if I hadn’t thought that that loan was a gift.
[00:48:31] Ramit: Mm-hmm. Okay. All right. Zoe, you don’t include that in your debt because why?
[00:48:36] Zoe: I did include it in my debt, I just didn’t include it as a debt payment because she gifted/loaned me $50,000.
[00:48:44] I paid her back $6,000 at the beginning of this year for the year, and then I’ll pay her back either when I sell the house or I can pay it in chunks.
[00:48:52] Ramit: Some other questions I have here. So I’m noting that your income is kind of, like, variable. I [00:49:00] see one month you were planned to make $10,600, you made $9,500.
[00:49:04] If we go back a month, you made $16,000. What’s that about?
[00:49:09] Zoe: Commissions. I have my regular work, and then I do some consulting on the side, and then I also just picked up another part-time thing. So I … My, my income is variable.
[00:49:22] Ramit: What do you do for a living?
[00:49:23] Zoe: I’m a chief revenue officer.
[00:49:25] Ramit: Okay, got it. So you do some consulting on the side as well.
[00:49:28] You have commissions, bonus as well. So if everything goes well in a year, how much do you make?
[00:49:35] Zoe: Probably between $160 and $175. And if everything goes poorly, I make, like, $144.
[00:49:43] Ramit: Got it. Just the base, 12K. Sean, what’s your reaction there? Sean’s laughing.
[00:49:47] Sean: Yeah. I don’t even know, man. That’s just like … It’s just crazy.
[00:49:51] Like, it’s like … And not crazy, like, it’s definitely imaginable, but, like, sometimes you don’t seem happy with that. And a [00:50:00] lot of people do not see that in a year ever. So- I don’t know why you need to do more, and more, and more, and more, and more. Just take a step back and chill, for real. It just seems like you don’t wanna stop.
[00:50:13] Like, you don’t have to take an extra job. There’s no way you need to do that. It doesn’t make sense. But if you don’t mind and you have the extra energy, why not? I’m, I support you, but it’s just, I don’t know, Energizer bunny type thing. I think you can, can chill with it. But I’m, I’m happy for you. Like, I mean, make 350 next.
[00:50:35] Why not? I’m happy, but I just think it’s, like, ridiculous to me. I would love to make that money. I would love it. I know what to do with it. I would invest a lot more than I am now. So, but yeah, that’s it. I don’t know.
[00:50:49] Ramit: I counted seven back and forths in that comment to Zoe. Why’d you do that? ‘
[00:50:55] Sean: Cause you asked for a reaction where I didn’t have anything in my brain.
[00:50:58] I was just laughing at how much it [00:51:00] was.
[00:51:00] Ramit: Yes, but you do that a lot. That’s a
[00:51:01] Sean: low estimate.
[00:51:02] Ramit: But you do that a lot. You go back and forth, you talk out of both sides of your mouth. You’re ambivalent. You feel this way, but also this way, but not that way, but also this way, but then that way, but then also this way.
[00:51:12] Why do you do it?
[00:51:12] Sean: Because I don’t wanna hurt her feelings.
[00:51:15] Ramit: I don’t know about that.
[00:51:16] Sean: That is true. I don’t know, because I have multiple things going through my head at once. That’s why.
[00:51:21] Ramit: So? I have a lot of things going through my head, doesn’t mean I say it all
[00:51:25] Sean: True
[00:51:26] Ramit: Why do you give multiple versions in one comment?
[00:51:31] Sean: I don’t know. I wanna explain myself, I think.
[00:51:34] Ramit: I think you don’t know how you actually feel, so you just start talking. Mm-hmm. And then as soon as you hear yourself talking, you realize, “Hmm, I don’t know about that,” that, or, “Maybe that doesn’t sound good,” or, “Gosh, I better think about making her feel better.
[00:51:45] Gosh, I don’t wanna come off looking bad, so let me reverse it.” But then as you say that, you go, “Wait a second, I actually don’t believe this. Let me reverse it again.” And now we’re back and back and back and back. How’s that strike you?
[00:51:55] Sean: Accurate.
[00:51:56] Ramit: Okay. It’s one thing to have a communication style that’s [00:52:00] confusing, ’cause it is confusing, but it’s an entirely another thing to be the recipient of that.
[00:52:04] It provides really mixed messages. So when you said, “I wanna be supportive,” that was actually not a supportive comment. It was actually really unsupportive. If somebody’s making the high income that Zoe’s making, what would a supportive comment look like? “
[00:52:18] Sean: Good for you.”
[00:52:19] Ramit: Yeah. Or to go even further, “Good for you.
[00:52:22] You work really hard. You do an awesome job. You’re so talented, and it’s great that this company recognizes you for the value you bring.” Super supportive. But if you were to tell a high achiever, like if you were to tell me, “Hey, Ramit, why don’t you just chill,” how do you think I would receive that?
[00:52:37] Sean: I think you’d say, “off.”
[00:52:39] Exactly.
[00:52:40] Ramit: Now, Zoe doesn’t do that because I think she’s probably a little bit nicer than I am, and you two are in an intimate relationship, so usually people don’t tell their partner to off. But I would if you told me that, and I would be like, “Why am I even listening to your advice? You don’t know what I do, what I took to get here.”
[00:52:54] Sean: You are absolutely right about this. And I do talk out of side of, both, both sides of my [00:53:00] mouth sometimes, and that’s because I a- I am kind of, what do you call it? Like, um, I’m working through it in the moment, and it, it’s definitely something I gotta work on. It really is.
[00:53:11] Ramit: Zoe, do you wanna add anything? Any reactions here?
[00:53:13] Zoe: You asked, “Where do you think that comes from?” And the thing that I thought about was when Sean was very young, he sort of- His parents’ divorce lasted, like, what, 10 years, 12 years, some ridiculous amount of time. Mm-hmm. And I think that he was put in the middle a lot, and so it makes sense to me that he would sort of go back and forth and back and- Oh,
[00:53:36] Ramit: the mediating
[00:53:36] Zoe: forth. It’s hard. Yeah, yeah, for sure.
[00:53:39] Sean: Okay, let’s talk about that.
[00:53:40] Ramit: Sean, what do you remember your family saying about money when you were
[00:53:43] Sean: young? They went through a divorce that ruined both of them financially. I’m the only child. I didn’t have a buffer. It was just me. So I grew up hearing, “We can’t afford that.
[00:53:53] We don’t have enough,” whatever. I got a good scholarship to a, a, a school where almost everyone was, was more well off than [00:54:00] I was, so I had a chip on my shoulder with that stuff.
[00:54:02] Ramit: Hmm. Tell, tell me about that.
[00:54:04] Sean: I was constantly being told, “No, you can’t. You can’t have this. You can’t have that.” Just like restrict, restrict, restrict, restrict, restrict.
[00:54:11] But, yeah, the chip on the shoulder I guess maybe with the entitled people or, or people who are perceived to, to have an easy life, I do judge harshly.
[00:54:21] Ramit: Because you had a tougher time? Is that why?
[00:54:25] Sean: Maybe. When I was 12 years old, I had a friend over, and he called me poor, and that stuck with me. It never left, and it created a good chip on my shoulder for it because I wasn’t, and my family is…
[00:54:39] Like, they’re pretty well off, honestly. Like, they’re all over the world right now, my dad’s side at least. But they saw my mom’s, and we were TV trays in front of the dinner, like, in front of the TV, and, and he’s like, “You guys are poor. I don’t wanna go back to your house.” I’m like, “Are you kidding me?” Mm.
[00:54:57] Good thing I wasn’t drinking then. Why [00:55:00] do you think that hit you so hard? My, my mom worked really hard. Uh-huh. She worked really hard to- Uh-huh … create what she did. She got so stressed, and she was the best she could be.
[00:55:11] Ramit: What does it mean that you work hard and your income is currently $37,000 a year?
[00:55:17] Sean: It makes me a little resentful, and that’s against my program.
[00:55:20] Uh-huh. The fourth step is all about resents, res- resentments. I resent that. I hate it.
[00:55:26] Ramit: What do you hate, or who do you hate?
[00:55:28] Sean: I hate that people have it easier- Uh-huh … when, or they don’t know how- I know it sounds like I’m entitled and I’m a victim, and I’m not. I wish people would have empathy for each other, and if they don’t know the meaning of the artwork and they just, like, maybe treat other people like um-
[00:55:43] Ramit: Mm.
[00:55:44] Sean: it doesn’t fly with me at all. I hate that. I- equality and respect, for sure. I’m not talking about specifics right now. I’m talking about-
[00:55:50] Ramit: I’m trying to get specific, though. You know, you use strong words, hatred. Yeah. And when somebody uses strong words, that’s a clue to me there’s something here, and I wanna know what it is.
[00:55:59] I don’t [00:56:00] mind that you are resentful of people who are entitled. I mean, in America, the word entitled is a negative connotation. Okay, but I wanna know why. Why is it so strong for you? Because, yeah, like, I went to college with a lot of people who had a lot more than I did. Did some of them have it easier than I did?
[00:56:17] Yeah. Did some of them have it harder? Yeah. I don’t have a hatred for the entitled, and I wanna know why you do.
[00:56:25] Sean: I don’t know yet
[00:56:27] Ramit: Okay. So you mentioned something about high school. You know, there was this kind of like make money type of thing, like maybe masculinity. Tell me a little bit more about that.
[00:56:37] Sean: Um, we did JROTC for four years. Mm-hmm. So it was military.
[00:56:41] Ramit: What do you take away from that?
[00:56:44] Sean: Money equals power, respect, and freedom.
[00:56:47] Ramit: And if I don’t have money, then I
[00:56:49] Sean: don’t- If I don’t have any of that, I ain’t got the respect, I ain’t got the money, and I, I ain’t, I mean, I ain’t got the freedom. For sure, that’s really what it is.
[00:56:56] I just don’t pay attention to the money/status aspects. [00:57:00] I mean, I try not to.
[00:57:02] Ramit: Yeah. Yeah. That’s pretty interesting. And I’m looking here, you know, I’m looking at your savings account, I’m looking at your credit card, the bills, the collections, all of that. Yeah. And if your view of money is having it is power, respect, access, and not having it is the lack of that- Yeah
[00:57:17] then that doesn’t feel good.
[00:57:19] Sean: No, it does not.
[00:57:22] Ramit: Sean’s relationship with money in childhood starts to shed a light on who he is today. What really stood out to me was when he told me the story about being called poor at the age of 12. Now, probably a lot of kids are called poor at some point, but for him in particular, at that formative age, in the environment he was in, tumultuous, parents separating, wealthy side of the family, but now he’s not there.
[00:57:49] You are in a situation that amplifies that type of comment, and it really has stuck with him. There are not many phrases that most of us remember back from age 12, but he [00:58:00] has a lot of resentment. He says, “I have a chip on my shoulder.” He used words like hate. “I hate entitled people.” Now, I will say this, I don’t mind a good chip on your shoulder.
[00:58:11] Sometimes it can be very functional. I’m not out here like everybody sing Kumbaya, let’s all be healthy. Sometimes you need to have a little bit of an unhealthy look on life in order to build excellence. So I don’t mind a chip, but the chip has got to help you, not hurt you. And when I’m talking to Sean, gosh, it’s really hard to connect because this chip is showing up in lots of different ways.
[00:58:37] In many ways, it’s not allowing him to hear what I’m even saying or what his partner Zoe is saying. It’s all being filtered through this defensive view, resentful view of money. I have hope, though. I do think there is a way to connect, because we all grow up with different views on money, but ultimately, we’re trying [00:59:00] to build something more powerful, something richer, something more connective.
[00:59:03] Sean: So that is what I’m trying to get to in my work with him and Zoe
[00:59:07] Ramit: I wanna thank our new partners at Monarch for setting up our couples on their platform to see their exact conscious spending plan categories. Monarch is a private personal finance app that brings all of a household’s accounts, checking credit cards, loans, and investments into one clean dashboard on your phone or computer.
[00:59:25] If you’re trying to pay off debt, Monarch makes it easy to see your progress. You can see your whole payoff timeline for credit cards and car loans in a way that you can clearly visualize. No more juggling apps or manually updating spreadsheets. I’ve always said that a rich life is lived outside of the spreadsheet, and Monarch lets you save time so you can do exactly that.
[00:59:47] Try Monarch for free today and get 50% off your first year of Monarch’s core tier with code ramit at monarch.com/ramit. And when you sign up with my link only, you’ll get your Monarch [01:00:00] account customized with my exact CSP categories so you can see how you are stacking up to your plan each month. That’s monarch.com/ramit with code ramit.
[01:00:12] Zoe, I wanna ask about your childhood. What do you remember about money growing up? What did your family say about it?
[01:00:20] Zoe: Until I was 11, I was the only daughter of a single mother. My mom worked, like, three jobs, the last of which was she became an accountant, and so I grew up talking about, like, interest amortization at the dinner table.
[01:00:33] Ramit: Wow.
[01:00:33] Zoe: So I had a lot of, like, early financial exposure, but not a lot of access to money early on in my life. But I had a way happier childhood, I think, until I was 11, and then my mom met and married my now ex-stepdad, and combined they had a lot more money, but I felt deeply abandoned by my mom. My stepdad was pretty abusive.
[01:00:58] They had another kid. [01:01:00] Like, so for me, I was so much happier without the money. For me, money didn’t equal happiness, and so I feel like I sort of had two different childhood experiences, one without a lot of stuff, and then, but a lot more love and attention and kindness, and then one where there was more money, uh, and a higher quality of living, but not all that money was directed towards me because felt like an outsider in my house.
[01:01:23] Ramit: Yeah. That’s kinda confusing.
[01:01:26] Zoe: Yeah. It… Well, and I’ve had to work a lot on my money psychology. Like, I know we’re looking at the numbers or a snapshot in time, but I really only got serious about working on money in the last, like, three years. I mean, I worked in finance in my 20s, had the eating disorder, was spending $300 a day on food, binging and purging 12 times a day.
[01:01:47] Um, you know, went into treatment and declared bankruptcy. So, like, I’ve had a really tortured relationship with money myself. It- it’s no longer there, and so I think sometimes, like, Sean sees the current me, but not all the [01:02:00] history.
[01:02:01] Ramit: Right. Well, that’s interesting. You’ve both gone through substantial, vivid journeys.
[01:02:08] So if we were to just look at where you are today, that may not fully capture the journey you’ve gone through, but at the same time, we do need to look at where you are today. Your, your journey is important to acknowledge and it informs where you are and, and everything, but also we need to also compare ourselves to where we are today and where we are trying to go.
[01:02:27] So something to consider. Zoe, do you think, you know, you were being taught about- amortization at the dining room table when you were, what, 12? 13?
[01:02:38] Zoe: Four. Yeah. My
[01:02:39] Ramit: mom- Four years old, you knew what amortization was?
[01:02:41] Zoe: Yeah. We got together with some family friends at one point. I think I was, like, four years old. I was in my high chair.
[01:02:47] I don’t remember this, but my mom tells this story, and her friend was talking at the table, and she said, “Yeah, we’re gonna, you know, refinance our house,” and I raised my, you know, I raised my hand, and I said, “Well, like, what is the, [01:03:00] like, what is your interest rate, and what is your amortization schedule?”
[01:03:03] Ramit: That’s the greatest childhood story I’ve ever heard in my life. This is amazing. Like, wow. Can a four-year-old even hold things in their hand? I don’t know. And here you are doing… This is crazy. I’ve never heard a story like this. Okay, so taking that, four years old, understanding advanced concepts that the vast majority of adult Americans do- they’ve never even heard that word.
[01:03:26] The two of you have such different upbringings with money. Not only a different understanding of money, but different feelings towards it. Sean, very resentful, as he puts it, of, quote, “entitled people.” You, a chief revenue officer who makes hundreds of thousands, and it’s, you know, routine to get a $20,000 bonus.
[01:03:51] Do you think that the differences in the way you see money, behave with money, feel about money, can be bridged?
[01:03:59] Zoe: I [01:04:00] think because I know what’s possible, and because I see how hard Sean works in every other aspect of his life, like, I definitely feel like if we could have an aligned vision, and if we could have a plan that we both feel some ownership over, I definitely think we could get on the same page.
[01:04:17] Ramit: I don’t actually think the plan is the challenge here. ‘Cause the two of you are capable. You could’ve made a plan on your own. You still can. The two of you see money so profoundly differently that any plan is secondary to your own money psychology. Now, could you come together? Yeah, you could. But each of you, particularly you, Sean, would have to change or add a new part to your money psychology.
[01:04:45] Because if you are combining families, the two of you, you are now a high-income family. That means you need to understand the language of high-income families. You need to understand the- thinking of high [01:05:00] income families, the social mores of high income families, all of those things that come together, and that work would fall on both of you, but it would fall more on you, Sean.
[01:05:10] That’s fine. Would you be open to that?
[01:05:12] Sean: Yeah, absolutely. I
[01:05:13] Ramit: mean- Great. Love that answer. It would contradict some of the ways that you think about money because as you put it, well, as… I’ll read off directly from the application that Zoe wrote very pointedly, kind of made you mad, Sean, but I’m gonna read it again.
[01:05:26] She said, “He hates rich people, and I am one.” If the two of you end up living together and then going on to get married as you mentioned, you will both be rich. Sean, how would, how would you grapple with that?
[01:05:40] Sean: I would gratefully accept it. I don’t hate rich people. I really don’t. I hate entitled people. I hate when entitled people do entitled things and say entitled things.
[01:05:51] It’s not rich people. I love people. I love individuals. I love people. I really do. I guess I don’t really have trust in, in- [01:06:00] In the elites. I don’t have trust in the government. I, you know, it’s, it’s what, it’s what power represents in, in my opinion. That’s what I, I don’t like the abuse of that stuff.
[01:06:10] Ramit: Okay.
[01:06:10] Sean: So oftentimes it’s muddled, and that’s my, that’s my bad because I’m not specific, and it’s not synonymous, those things.
[01:06:18] Ramit: Zoe, you wrote it. Do you agree with what Sean is saying, or do you indeed agree as you wrote, “He hates rich people, and I am one”?
[01:06:24] Zoe: I think there’s Sean’s ideal and his heart, but I think the reality of his financial situation is so stressful that he lashes out at people who have money.
[01:06:36] Ramit: Okay. So how do we resolve this?
[01:06:37] Because my goal is not to sit here and blame people. That’s not what I’m here for. I’m here to help you hopefully find a way to connect over money and to build a joint vision of money. Yeah. Do you have a joint vision of money?
[01:06:49] Zoe: I think we absolutely do. We both want to get a house together, build a life together.
[01:06:57] Sean wants two kids. I want one, but we’re gonna try [01:07:00] for two and see how that goes. Yeah. I know that Sean loves to travel, and that’s super important to him, particularly as he mentioned, he has family all over the world, so, like, going to visit that family but also going to just destinations. I know it’s important for him to have a house with a yard at some point.
[01:07:18] He wants a dog. For me, the thing that’s most important is the motherhood component. So, you know, I think we have a lot of compatibility.
[01:07:27] Ramit: Okay, great. I wanna go back to your CSP, and I wanna make some changes.
[01:07:31] Zoe: Yeah, sure.
[01:07:31] Ramit: How do you feel about that? Good. All right. Sean, you, you good?
[01:07:35] Sean: Sure, yeah.
[01:07:36] Ramit: Let’s do it. All right, I’m gonna put it up.
[01:07:37] So here’s the current situation, okay? Together now making approximately $180,000 a year. Mm-hmm. That’s a lot of money, and yet if we combine all expenses, you’re at 92% fixed costs, so that doesn’t work. So we need to change that, and honestly, at almost $180,000, this number should be way lower [01:08:00] because you are right now in a golden age.
[01:08:02] No kids, dual income. If you can’t make it work with ease right now, it’s only gonna get harder. And yeah, I’m sure both of your incomes are gonna go up, which is great, but life is relatively simple now, so let’s just fix it. Let’s just make it work. Okay. So here’s what I wanna do. The goal is to try to get these numbers down to 60%, so I wanna figure that out.
[01:08:25] How can we do that?
[01:08:26] Zoe: We can adjust the income number. A- as of next month, I’ll be making $1,000 more a month, but also I didn’t account for my bonus. So if you wanna add in another like $6,000 for the year.
[01:08:40] Ramit: So let’s put 500 plus 1,000. That’s 1,500 total. Let’s- Mm-hmm … net it out at what? 1,000?
[01:08:47] Zoe: Yeah, maybe $1,000 then.
[01:08:48] Yeah.
[01:08:48] Ramit: All right, great. So we’ll put this number to 9,432. Are you cool with that? Okay. Watch the number change. Wow, 92% went down to 84%. Good work. What’s next? [01:09:00] Sean?
[01:09:00] Sean: I think food can definitely be adjusted.
[01:09:05] Ramit: You spend 400, she spends 1,194.
[01:09:08] Sean: Yeah.
[01:09:09] Ramit: That’s quite a disparity. Let’s look at the groceries. 1,800 bucks in one month.
[01:09:13] Like, you’re going to a co-op three times in a day? What’s that?
[01:09:17] Zoe: I don’t know. It’s mostly buying pre-prepared, pre-packaged foods. And then sometimes I’ll shop for me, and then he’ll decide to come over and I’ll buy some stuff for the both of us, and I didn’t really plan for that necessarily, so…
[01:09:31] Ramit: So what do you think about this?
[01:09:33] Zoe: It’s definitely sloppy. Um, I also, being in recovery from an eating disorder, I feel like just dealing with my housing and my subscriptions and all of that is an easier thing to tackle. So I have sort of focused there. But I’m willing to make changes.
[01:09:51] Ramit: Well, that’s a fair critique. So so- you know what, I think a lot of times health can override other things.
[01:09:55] So if you were to tell me, “Hey, Ramit, this is obviously [01:10:00] really expensive relative to other things. However, this is my priority- Mm-hmm … for health reasons or convenience reasons or XYZ reasons. And I know it’s more, but I just wanna do that. I want to spend extravagantly there, and I’m willing to cut costs mercilessly elsewhere,” I’ll make it work.
[01:10:15] You tell me, though, is it that important to you?
[01:10:18] Zoe: I would say that once Sean and I are living together, I feel very comfortable getting that number down to maybe 900 or 950. I think when I’m by myself, I prefer to spend as little time with food as possible.
[01:10:29] Ramit: So when, when you move in together, is Sean gonna be the one doing the food prep?
[01:10:33] Zoe: No. I do a lot of the cooking for the two of us. I just, when I’m by myself with food, I don’t want a lot of food around, so…
[01:10:40] Ramit: All right. That makes sense. Okay. Are you cool with that, Sean?
[01:10:42] Sean: Yeah, totally.
[01:10:43] Ramit: All right. So 900. So that’s dropping it by, like, half.
[01:10:47] Zoe: Yeah, I’d say, like, 950, I would say.
[01:10:49] Ramit: 950. Let’s go ahead and make the change.
[01:10:51] Keep an eye on the 84% at the top. We’re going from 1,594 to 950. We’re down to 78%. Okay. I think 950 is reasonable [01:11:00] and a little on the high side for two. But then again, you make $180,000, so yeah, go ahead. I’m not trying to have you get the cheapest stuff. It’s fine. Next, what do you wanna cut?
[01:11:10] Zoe: Well, the rent and the mortgage and the debt payment on my side are gonna go down pretty considerably once the house sells.
[01:11:17] Ramit: How much is it gonna go down to?
[01:11:19] Zoe: 1,900 max.
[01:11:22] Ramit: 1,900. And that’s for total?
[01:11:24] Zoe: Uh, yes.
[01:11:25] Ramit: Wow. Sean’s gonna go to 250. Is that right?
[01:11:28] Zoe: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
[01:11:29] Ramit: Watch this. Watch the number at the top. 75% now. 69%.
[01:11:35] Zoe: But also the, the debt payment for me, the HELOC, will go away. So- This
[01:11:40] Ramit: one? 694?
[01:11:41] Zoe: That’s… Yeah.
[01:11:42] Ramit: Watch the number. 63%. There we
[01:11:45] Sean: go.
[01:11:45] We’re getting closer.
[01:11:46] Ramit: Utilities have to come down when you are having a smaller- Maybe renting
[01:11:50] Zoe: And we’ll be living together, so I think Sean’s utilities will go away.
[01:11:54] Ramit: Okay.
[01:11:55] Zoe: Um-
[01:11:55] Ramit: 62% next. Groceries we nailed. [01:12:00] Clothes, all right, fine. Miscellaneous is a lot. Let’s take a look at miscellaneous. I wanna go back another month.
[01:12:06] Miscellaneous at 130. Okay. Natural Chinese herbs. Okay.
[01:12:12] Zoe: Acupuncture, yes.
[01:12:13] Ramit: Let’s go back another month. I wanna see what else is going on with this miscellaneous. Miscellaneous one month, $4. Wow. I’m actually surprised. It’s pretty dialed in actually. Mm-hmm. There’s not a lot. $76. Let’s take this number down.
[01:12:25] What are we doing? It’s definitely not $1,019. Let’s put it at 200, okay? Are you good with that, Zoe?
[01:12:31] Zoe: It’s probably gonna be more like four at least.
[01:12:34] Ramit: Okay. I love the pushback. Great. 400 it is. Watch the number at the top. 62 down to 56%. This is big. You wanna keep going? What’s up with these subscriptions? Back to Monarch, looking at the subscriptions.
[01:12:47] Amazon, Anytime Fitness, Spotify, YouTube, SoundCloud, Amazon, HBO. It’s very obvious to me which one I would kill off of this, but you tell me.
[01:12:56] Zoe: He could cancel his Amazon, and we could just [01:13:00] use, share mine, but that’s only, like, $5, so I don’t
[01:13:02] Ramit: know. Oh, five bucks. I don’t… I’m not even gonna spend time typing it in.
[01:13:05] Zoe: Yeah.
[01:13:06] Ramit: All right. I
[01:13:06] Sean: can’t believe it’s $5 still for me. What?
[01:13:08] Ramit: Okay. Just to look at annually where your money is going, take a look at this. So we see housing, right? Sean, remember earlier on you were saying, like, “Well, you know, it’s like you can easily afford it,” et cetera. This actually shows that it’s the biggest area of opportunity.
[01:13:25] So I think you both made a great decision, Zoe, you in particular, to downsize. You have the cash that’s gonna wipe out debt. Mm-hmm. You have a cheaper place. That’s actually quite counterculture, quite unusual. “Hey, we’re trying for a baby. My income’s going up, and I’m gonna downsize.” If you don’t care about a house, that’s the biggest opportunity you have.
[01:13:47] Looking at the rest, look at this. Debt payments is almost neck and neck. 28.2% of expenses over the last year for debt payments.
[01:13:56] Zoe: Mm-hmm.
[01:13:57] Ramit: What do you think about that?
[01:13:58] Zoe: So for [01:14:00] me, my most important thing is being a mom, and so I know that that’s all, like, IVF payments. So I don’t feel-
[01:14:07] Ramit: Uh-huh …
[01:14:07] Zoe: badly about that, uh, you know, on my side at all.
[01:14:10] I f- I just feel like it’s a reality, and I don’t regret it at all. I’m really hopefully gonna be very grateful one day if that results in a baby. So I think if … Like, I don’t have a problem with debt, I have a problem with, like, what is this debt- Yeah … attached to. And so it was a very thoughtful choice and decision, you know, that I made to take on that debt.
[01:14:29] Ramit: All right. Sean, when is your debt gonna be paid off? It depends on, on my next job. Do you have a debt payoff plan?
[01:14:37] Sean: No.
[01:14:37] Ramit: Yeah. You’re paying- With what,
[01:14:39] Sean: with what money, though? It’s, like, I need, I need to get a better job, man. That’s what it is. Um.
[01:14:43] Ramit: Well, okay. Yeah, I agree with that, but let’s just look. You’re paying $170 towards debt right now.
[01:14:48] Where’s that going?
[01:14:49] Sean: To the US government.
[01:14:52] Ramit: That’s your IRS debt?
[01:14:54] Sean: That is included in that. $50 in that is going to a collection agency. As an [01:15:00] aside, really quick, I actually pay more in debt a month. I think I was conservative here. I pay about 230 or 240, honestly.
[01:15:07] Ramit: All right. Let’s take a look at the accounts.
[01:15:09] So if we take a look at the debt here, the credit card is $1,000. That’s … Zoe, I assume that’s yours? All right? And then if we look at the liabilities, you have $13,000. So we have Sean’s collections, 2,200. Sean’s collections, 1,800. Sean’s collections, 1,400, and then federal taxes, $7,800.
[01:15:33] Sean: Yes.
[01:15:33] Ramit: For a total of $13,000.
[01:15:36] Okay. Sean, have you contacted these companies and spoken to them?
[01:15:40] Sean: All but one.
[01:15:41] Ramit: Okay, that’s good. So here’s my question for you, Sean. When you know these and you know the interest rates on them, you can plug them into a debt payoff calculator. You could literally search Ramit debt payoff calculator, and you will know the exact month and year that your debt will be paid off.
[01:15:58] After our call, [01:16:00] can you plug those numbers in and find out?
[01:16:02] Sean: Absolutely.
[01:16:03] Ramit: Now, I think there’s some positive news that you can factor in here, which is when you move in together, your rent is gonna be saving you, I think something like three or 400 bucks a month. That’s a lot of money. Where does that money go?
[01:16:17] Sean: So I, I think the best thing to do is pay off debt, honestly. I
[01:16:20] Ramit: agree.
[01:16:21] Sean: My car isn’t doing well, okay? So that’s gonna be the next thing that fails. So I don’t know where that comes in with all this, but I can’t get a job without a car around here really as much. So I think I should pay off debt, but I probably should put some of that toward-
[01:16:34] Ramit: No, no, no.
[01:16:34] We’re not doing this two-sided thing. I need one answer. I need you to stop doing the two-sided thing. It’s not working for me anymore. It’s definitely not working for you. Think before you give me an answer, come up with a plan in your head, and then tell me. You’re gonna make an extra… I think it’s actually more like $400 a month.
[01:16:51] Sean: Yeah.
[01:16:52] Ramit: What do you wanna do with the money? Think about it. Take your time. Tell me whenever you’re ready.
[01:16:56] Sean: Save it. Invest it. I do not wanna pay off debt more than I am right now. [01:17:00] I wanna save it, and I wanna invest together. That’s one
[01:17:05] Ramit: You wanna save it and invest it. Those are two separate things.
[01:17:08] Sean: Okay, I wanna invest it.
[01:17:10] Ramit: Okay, you wanna invest it, and okay, that’s a very crisp answer. Now, out of curiosity, why do you wanna do that versus, uh, paying off debt?
[01:17:18] Sean: Because I can make more with it invested while keeping the same pace I am now. I’d rather have my future than-
[01:17:26] Ramit: Okay …
[01:17:27] Sean: current strife.
[01:17:28] Ramit: Well, I wanna say this. First of all, I like your answer.
[01:17:30] I like that you paused and really thought it through. I actually think you are at your best when you slow it down and pause, and sometimes, I’ve heard you once on this call, you said, “Hey, let me think about that for a second.” And I actually love that. I love when people do that. I would rather get a slow answer that’s right than a fast five answers that are wrong.
[01:17:52] So I love your answer.
[01:17:54] Sean: Thanks. I come from a family where we are all speed talkers. We’re from New York. My, my father in particular, very [01:18:00] fast, and yeah, I guess.
[01:18:01] Ramit: Get rid of that, Sean. I
[01:18:02] Sean: know.
[01:18:03] Ramit: Get rid of that tendency. It’s not serving you well.
[01:18:06] Sean: Okay.
[01:18:06] Ramit: Powerful people don’t talk fast. They don’t need to. When I talk, I know people are gonna listen.
[01:18:12] And if you wanna go watch any celebrity on TV, they don’t need to talk fast. They know you’re gonna listen, and they have something important to say. So do both of those things. It’s gonna serve you really well.
[01:18:22] Zoe: Okay? Okay.
[01:18:23] Ramit: One way or another, I would like for you to make a plan of what is going to change when you both move in together.
[01:18:32] ‘Cause it’s actually gonna change a lot in a really positive way. And to put this back up on screen just so you can see it, you can see that we’re down to 56% fixed costs. Obviously, we’ve brought your housing costs way down, and we made all these changes. What we didn’t really tackle was the differences between how each of you is gonna spend.
[01:18:53] So for example, living together, in my opinion, but not married, I think you should have a joint account. I do. But that joint account [01:19:00] should only be used for joint expenses, things like food, et cetera. I don’t recommend people combine everything until they get married. Okay? So if you have food combined and you’re doing a joint account probably proportionally, then Zoe, because you make so much more, you’re gonna be paying more for food, as I think is appropriate.
[01:19:18] Sean will be paying, but he’ll be paying proportionately less. Make sense?
[01:19:23] Sean: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
[01:19:23] Ramit: All right.
[01:19:24] Sean: Yeah.
[01:19:24] Ramit: Any questions on that is in my Money For Couples book. It’ll show you the math and how to do it. But overall, by combining, you’re gonna save a considerable amount of money, ’cause you don’t need two Amazon accounts anymore.
[01:19:34] You can save on food, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. Mm-hmm. So what that really means is, okay, so what do we get? If Sean is now saving hundreds of dollars a month, Sean’s gotta make a plan for what he’s gonna do with the money. Sean, I like the way you’re thinking. Invest it. Thank you. Or save some of it.
[01:19:51] All totally good options, up to the two of you how you wanna decide it, okay? All right. Zoe, same for you. You have upcoming cash [01:20:00] requirements that are gonna be probably pretty expensive.
[01:20:02] Zoe: Yes, except that our current plan, I mean, I was planning to put $1,000 of the money that I’m making extra towards a future IVF cycle if we try to have a second-
[01:20:13] Ramit: Great.
[01:20:14] You put that in a savings account?
[01:20:16] Zoe: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
[01:20:16] Ramit: I like it. I like it. Okay, great. You’re thinking ahead. That’s awesome. That’s how I want both of you to be thinking. Zoe, I think you’re a little bit ahead, one, because you were learning about complex financial stuff at age four, but two, I also think you have the ability to do that because you earn so much money.
[01:20:35] So Sean is like, “I need a better job,” like bottom line. “I can’t really afford to think much further ahead.” What I’ve done with Sean is to show him, no, you actually can think a little bit ahead. You have a few extra hundred dollars a month, which is substantial, put it to work, plan ahead. But obviously, if we’re talking about planning years ahead or planning tens of thousands of dollars ahead, that involves a better job for you, Sean.
[01:20:58] I agree.
[01:20:59] Sean: Oh, [01:21:00] yeah.
[01:21:00] Ramit: Okay. I’m feeling pretty positive so far. How are you both feeling?
[01:21:04] Sean: Better.
[01:21:05] Ramit: Yeah. Yeah. Zoe?
[01:21:07] Zoe: I feel grateful, but also a little anxious. Okay. I don’t want it to seem like I don’t have any room to grow, ’cause I absolutely do.
[01:21:15] Ramit: Okay. Tell me where you think there’s an area of opportunity or an area you feel challenged in.
[01:21:21] Zoe: When it comes to communicating with Sean about money, I wanna have a better way to do that. I don’t know if it’s like my approach or his receptivity or probably 50/50 both, but, um, like I wanna be able to have conversations where it feels like we’re building from the beginning, not tearing things down and then having to like rebuild.
[01:21:45] Ramit: Okay.
[01:21:46] Zoe: And I wanna be clear about like what my part is in that ’cause I don’t really totally know.
[01:21:51] Ramit: Mm-hmm. What is a topic that if we were to end this call right now, you feel this would be a really tough topic to talk about with Sean?
[01:21:59] Zoe: [01:22:00] Okay. So I’m making more and more money, and I’m pretty deliberate about my goals, both for myself and for us.
[01:22:09] So for example, like when I’m making a thousand extra dollars a month, I wanna put that money towards a future baby fund. I feel like Sean will see that and be like, “I’m struggling so much.”
[01:22:23] Ramit: Yeah. “
[01:22:23] Zoe: And you have all this extra money that you’re stockpiling,” and like, “Why am I struggling and you’re-” Yep
[01:22:30] basically doing a really great job.” Like-
[01:22:32] Ramit: Okay, I understand. So what would your answer be?
[01:22:34] Zoe: Well, I’m willing to help him and support him on our present, but like I feel like it’s his job to figure out his past and, and I’m really oriented towards the present and the future, and I’m willing to absorb some stress, but I’m not gonna give up my dreams to like throw him a life preserver.
[01:22:51] Okay. And I believe in him too much to- think that he needs that. Like, I think he can easily achieve 10 or 15 more [01:23:00] thousand dollars a year while also saving $1,000 a month because we’re living together.
[01:23:05] Ramit: Okay, that was a lot. Can you give it to me in one sentence?
[01:23:08] Zoe: I think I would say I love you, but it’s not my responsibility.
[01:23:11] Sean: Great. Sean, how would you take that? Um, I don’t think that’s fair, and I don’t agree. Because honestly, like, why would you save for… I mean, you can save a little bit, but, like, why would you let me struggle? I wouldn’t do that for you. I would, I would help you out.
[01:23:27] Ramit: How do you know what you would do if you made $180,000?
[01:23:30] Sean: I know my character. I know my character, and anyone who I love, I will help out.
[01:23:36] Ramit: I’m sorry.
[01:23:36] Sean: Absolutely.
[01:23:37] Ramit: I’m sorry. It’s in my ability, unfortunately. So isn’t she helping you out by paying more of the housing costs? Isn’t she p- helping you out by- Yeah. No,
[01:23:44] Sean: not yet …
[01:23:44] Ramit: more proportionately? Not yet, because- Excuse me.
[01:23:46] I’ll finish talking on my own show. Isn’t she helping you out by paying more proportionally for all of the joint expenses, including groceries, including subscriptions, including all of the things that we covered?
[01:23:59] Sean: Yeah. [01:24:00] Yes. Yes. But- So
[01:24:01] Ramit: how is she not helping you out?
[01:24:03] Sean: It’s not that, dude. I didn’t say that. I said I would.
[01:24:06] I didn’t say she wasn’t. I said I would.
[01:24:09] Ramit: But she is doing that.
[01:24:10] Sean: Yeah, she is about to when I move down here, yeah, but I still have to find a job. I’m gonna be giving up my job. I’m gonna be giving up my security to do this. It’s still scary. The whole thing is still based in fear.
[01:24:21] Ramit: Sean, I appreciate that it can be scary to you, but that does not mean that it’s her responsibility to- Okay
[01:24:27] pay for you.
[01:24:27] Sean: Oh, yeah. Okay. Okay. Valid. Valid. Valid.
[01:24:33] Ramit: One thing that I think is concerning to me, Sean, is that you have a lot of complex emotions around money, and they come out in a way that’s not focused on you. Like you rarely say, “That’s scary to me. I feel insecure. I feel worried. I feel angry.” What you say is, “Zoe, you should be helping me out.
[01:24:51] I would never let this situation happen.” But it’s not about Zoe, it’s actually about you.
[01:24:57] Sean: Okay. Cool. Thank you. [01:25:00] Thank you. And yes, it is about me. You’re right. W- my problems are about me. I know. I’m not asking her to help me out. I didn’t… It wasn’t my choice to fall in love with her. It wasn’t, but I did.
[01:25:12] Ramit: So when you have this conversation where Zoe is concerned that you might say, “Hey, you’re putting aside $1,000 a month when I’m struggling.”
[01:25:20] Sean: This is, this is what my response is w- would be. You’re free to do with what, what you want with your own money, and I w- hopefully would be able to contribute to that in the future, too. And, you know, hopefully if I’m, I’m making at least 60 a year, yeah, actually even like 40, 50, yes, I would contribute to that.
[01:25:41] Ramit: Zoe, do you buy this?
[01:25:44] Zoe: Yeah. I think that Sean almost … Sean and I almost always get to the same place, but I think his first reaction tends to be not his ultimate reaction, but it’s still upsetting or disturbing, and we have to, like, grapple with that and then get to a [01:26:00] place. I just wish he could take a little bit more time and get to that final reaction, ’cause I do genuinely believe that he is supportive of me and will be on board with whatever I choose to do with my own money, but- Why
[01:26:11] Ramit: do you believe that?
[01:26:12] Zoe: Well, for example, like with the house, I mean, his first reaction was, “No, I don’t understand, and that’s, like, too much, and it’s too soon, and chill out,” and… but then I think he took some time and came back and was like, “Yeah, okay. Like, you know your numbers. I trust your judgment, and I think it’s really cool.”
[01:26:31] And that has been every money conversation that we’ve had. Like, it’s an argument followed by a reconciliation, followed by us doing it in a way that, you know, feels pretty aligned, but I don’t like how we get there. Do you think that’s a healthy
[01:26:43] Ramit: dynamic?
[01:26:44] Zoe: No, I don’t like how we get there. I think it’s not
[01:26:48] Ramit: great.
[01:26:48] ‘Cause I would be very hurt if I brought something up with my partner, and by the way, I happened to be right most of the time, and my partner’s initial reaction most of the [01:27:00] time was to fight back, was to argue, was to tell me things like, “Chill out,” and then we end up doing the thing that I proposed in the first place, and this happens every time we talk about money.
[01:27:10] I would feel pretty hurt. I wouldn’t wanna talk about money. I would start to feel resentful. I would start to look down on my partner because why don’t they get it? I’ve tried to work with them multiple times, and they’re fighting me, and then in the end, they end up doing it anyway. I would start to be pretty upset.
[01:27:26] What do you think, Zoe?
[01:27:27] Zoe: Yeah, I think, I mean, there’s, like, fight, flight, freeze. My reaction is freeze, so I don’t really do the fight or s- flight. I’m just shut down.
[01:27:36] Ramit: Are you angry?
[01:27:37] Zoe: Not so much. I think I’m more disappointed or sad, but I’m not… I don’t really resonate with being angry.
[01:27:44] Ramit: Mm-hmm. Sad. Is there any evidence that this dynamic’s gonna change in the future?
[01:27:49] Zoe: I don’t know, ’cause I’m a very optimistic person, so I think your question was about evidence. I feel like I focus on the fact that we always get to a pretty good place in [01:28:00] the end. I don’t, so I don’t know.
[01:28:02] Ramit: Part of my rich life philosophy is that it’s not just about the destination. Mm-hmm. I rarely talk only about a number.
[01:28:11] Okay? Like, are we gonna have this much? Are we gonna have that much? Yeah, we should calculate it, and we should know it. Okay, great. But the journey, the process of getting there, is actually supposed to be fun. It’s supposed to be enjoyable. We’re supposed to spend on the things we love. We’re supposed to be able to talk to our partner.
[01:28:28] We’re not supposed to be having a reflexive contrarianism with our partner, and that is really concerning to me. It’s disappointing for a while, then it becomes quiet because you just don’t wanna talk about it with your partner. Then it becomes resentment. Then it becomes protection. I need to protect myself and/or our kid or kids from this type of energy, and then it goes on from there.
[01:28:54] Yes, you are optimistic. That’s great, but I also want you to be a realist.
[01:28:57] Zoe: And I am. I think because [01:29:00] 90% of our relationship is fun and playful and joyful, and the 10% of our relationship that feels really hard and painful to me is the money stuff. Let’s bring that up to a six or a seven, and, like, then this relationship will be so much better-
[01:29:15] Ramit: Love
[01:29:15] Zoe: that
[01:29:15] Ramit: for me. Now, what was his reaction? I love the way you said that. What was his reaction?
[01:29:19] Zoe: He was actually very receptive to it. I mean, I said it sort of at the end of one of these arguments but then he was like, “Yeah, you’re right. I agree,” and- When was
[01:29:26] Ramit: that?
[01:29:27] Zoe: Maybe a couple weeks ago maybe? I don’t know.
[01:29:30] Ramit: And since then?
[01:29:31] Zoe: Going on this show has been maybe more stressful and anxiety producing, so I don’t know. But I would like to see- A bigger change. I wish that he would ask me more, like I have so much expertise in this area. Like I wish that he would come to me and say like, “Hey, what do you think about my financial prospects?”
[01:29:55] Ramit: Has he asked you questions about money?
[01:29:57] Zoe: Yes. Like the house buying process, [01:30:00] he’s asked me about that kind of thing. I don’t feel like he asks me anything about his money. He’s asked me about my money, but I don’t think he’s asked me about his money. I
[01:30:07] Sean: haven’t asked you about your money, babe. It, it, I’ve asked you about money stuff, like what do you, what’s your philosophy?
[01:30:13] I, I’m not asking her about net worth stuff. Proceed. I know you guys were talking, so just wanted to interject. I don’t like to be misre- represented. And I know, Ramit. I mean, I know you’re, I’m the focus now of your, of your wrath, but I do appreciate what you’re- I do- I do no, I do appreciate, though. I, I do, um-
[01:30:33] Ramit: Sean, I think you’re careless with your words, and it affects the people around you.
[01:30:37] Sean: Okay. Thank you.
[01:30:37] Ramit: Just as you just said wrath. I don’t think I’ve shown you wrath. You haven’t seen a- No, I’m,
[01:30:42] Sean: I’m being sarcastic … tenth of the
[01:30:43] Ramit: wrath. Don’t interrupt me. I’m being- When you use words like that, it affects the people around you. Now, I’m a professional, and I can take it, but if I were your intimate partner like Zoe, I would not be so nice.
[01:30:52] And when you use words carelessly like wrath, they do not serve you well. The point of coming here is to connect with your partner. [01:31:00] It is not to make sure that you’re interjecting every time. And so I’m sharing this direct feedback with you because I suspect most people in your life do not. Zoe wrote some very direct things in her application.
[01:31:13] That is why I decided to speak to both of you. And what I’m hearing right now, after hours of talking to you and actually making, I thought, some pretty good progress, it feels like we’ve come right back to square one. What’s your reaction to that?
[01:31:26] Sean: That I’m going through it, man. I didn’t wanna really come on this show because it’s, this is the worst topic for me ever.
[01:31:33] I’m vulnerable right now. I feel like you’re beating me up, dude. Okay. I’m really try- I am trying. But I do feel like you’re being a, a to me, okay? I, I’m trying. But it’s all defense, okay? When I’m, when I’m speaking out my the side of my mouth like that, it’s a defense mechanism. I, I don’t know. I l- I love her.
[01:31:55] We don’t, we really don’t fight often, but if we do, it’s about money. [01:32:00] So, you know. I don’t know. Whatever you wanna do, man. But like I appreciate your advice. I have, it has not fallen on deaf ears. But this is a touchy subject for me, Ramit, so I’m gonna be a little defensive.
[01:32:14] Zoe: Mm-hmm.
[01:32:15] Sean: So I can’t control it right now.
[01:32:17] Okay? I do want help. I want help with all, all of this stuff. I really do. I- Okay.
[01:32:22] Zoe: Thank you. I appreciate that.
[01:32:24] Sean: Yeah, y- yep.
[01:32:26] Ramit: You know, Sean called me a . Sean interrupted me many times, and I kind of love it. I don’t really get talked to that often in this way. And although, yes, it’s a little rude, what I love is that Sean is being authentically himself.
[01:32:43] He is not putting on any facade whatsoever, and I love that. I also think it could only be him. It could only be Sean with the cumulative collection of his life [01:33:00] experiences coming on this show and talking to me like that. And so, yeah, all right. It- sometimes it may feel a little rude to be talked to like that, but if I zoom out and I look at it and I see the chess pieces on the board, I appreciate that Sean is saying these things because it is very revealing, and it actually provides a way for them both to see what’s going on here.
[01:33:21] And then it’s up to them if they wanna choose to change it or not. Zoe, you mentioned that you wish Sean would ask you questions. What else do you expect in this relationship when it comes to money?
[01:33:34] Zoe: I just would like to feel super supported. I wanna feel like he sees a light at the end of the tunnel for himself.
[01:33:42] Ramit: What about for you? Not for him, for you.
[01:33:45] Zoe: Like, uplifting and receptive- Mm-hmm … to me bringing things up or sharing where, what’s going on with my money or work or whatever. I want him to be maybe more of a learner. He’s so curious [01:34:00] and such a learner in every other a- aspect of his life, but I feel like there’s, like, a level of avoidance here that’s really hard for me to navigate.
[01:34:08] I, I want to have joint financial goals and to work towards those and to feel like we’re both chipping away and, like, not necessarily equally, but, like, equitably. And- Mm-hmm … I think there’s such a level of defensiveness that it just feels so hard, this topic, and this is a topic that I’ve worked very hard to have a lot of ease in my life.
[01:34:32] Ramit: Yeah.
[01:34:32] Zoe: And so it’s challenging to have a partner who is the opposite of that at times.
[01:34:36] Ramit: Yeah, that’s pretty honest. Sean, do you wanna respond?
[01:34:39] Sean: Yeah, I agree. That’s it.
[01:34:41] Ramit: Okay. Yeah. Thank you. Yeah. I like what you said. It’s interesting that both of you have talked about how great the relationship is except for this one topic.
[01:34:52] Mm-hmm. I’ve heard that from both of you, and if it were me, my expectation would be that money is a very important part [01:35:00] of this relationship, and I expect us to be as good with money as we are with everything else. If not, this doesn’t work for me. Because I think money is one of those topics that gets papered over.
[01:35:12] You know, people are like, “Oh, we’re in love. It’s great. We’re all aligned on everything, but not money.” But when people say that, I think they often are thinking of money as just, like, some spreadsheet or once every two months we have to have a fight about this or that. No. Money is about will you direct funds toward IVF?
[01:35:28] Money is about will you hire specialists if you need help? Childcare. Money’s about where are we gonna live? What are we gonna eat? What are we gonna do? What kind of family do we wanna create? And it’s not a throwaway topic that comes out of the closet once every two months. It’s actually every day. It’s who you are.
[01:35:48] If you can’t agree on that, then in my opinion, I think you have a serious problem. If, on the other hand, you can both start to have a shared vision, I think there’s a chance. [01:36:00] When I met my wife and we started really talking about money, we had a lot of very tough conversations. We did a lot of work. We still do a lot of work.
[01:36:10] At one point, there was a information gap. I knew more about money than she did, and I told her, “Hey, this is causing a lot of problems, and you need to get good at this. It’s that important.” And she listened. She went off and learned money, and it has been incredibly valuable to us. She also told me, “You need to get more in touch with the way you feel because you’re just talking numbers and cents, and we need to connect more deeply over this.”
[01:36:40] And I had a lot of work to do, which I continue. I haven’t heard that level of direct communication Especially from you, Zoe, to Sean. Mm-hmm. “Hey, this isn’t working for me. Like, money isn’t just a tiny thing. I don’t expect you to know every single intricate detail, but I need you to have a base knowledge, and I [01:37:00] need you to work through your defensiveness.
[01:37:02] We’re talking about a life together, and I just, I will not be in a relationship where every conversation about money is met with defensiveness or contrarianism. Teammates don’t do that. Teammates listen. In fact, teammates come with their own things they wanna talk about. We do it together, and I welcome that.
[01:37:19] But this is what I need from you.” Zoe, how does that strike you?
[01:37:23] Zoe: I’ve definitely said I want more. I don’t think I’ve said it as an ultimatum. I don’t know that I feel like it’s an ultimatum, but I definitely feel like it’s very important to me that Sean work on his own money psychology, and I’ve said that, um, not just for me or for the relationship, but also for himself.
[01:37:39] Ramit: Okay. Zoe, you wrote the application to me. I wanna make sure you get everything you wanted out of today. What questions, if any, do you still have?
[01:37:46] Zoe: I feel disappointed, but I also was able to see the pattern that I experience, and so I felt s- sort of validated, but also disappointed.
[01:37:56] Ramit: Disappointed because?
[01:37:58] Zoe: Because I feel like this is such an [01:38:00] amazing opportunity, and I think the attitude that I brought to it was maybe more passive than the attitude that Sean brought to it, was combative or defensive. And so the conscious spending plan, we made some big changes, but those were changes that we’d already operationalized.
[01:38:17] So I don’t, I don’t wanna say it feels like a waste of time, because it wasn’t. I think it’s valuable to have this experience, and I’m very, very grateful for it, but I also feel like we did not make the most of it.
[01:38:32] Ramit: I think that’s pretty insightful. I- Mm-hmm … I actually really appreciate your ability to access how you feel in this very moment.
[01:38:38] That’s a very advanced skill that I constantly work on doing. And for you to kind of lay that out there, it’s really striking. It strikes me as very courageous, very self-perceptive, and I happen to agree a lot. I think that I feel unresolved about this. I feel [01:39:00] that we did not get to the very potential of what I think is possible, and I found that- Going on topics, there was almost like, um, a force field up for every topic, or if I opened any door, it was locked.
[01:39:17] And it takes a lot for you to come here. As Sean has mentioned, this is a very difficult topic for him. I respect that. Money is hard. To come here, it’s difficult. I get it. How do you think this might have gone differently?
[01:39:29] Zoe: I think that if we’d both come to this with an attitude of, like, let’s just set aside ego, let’s set aside agenda, and let’s just be open to learning, absorbing as much as we can, I think that it would have been different.
[01:39:43] I think that Sean is someone who really internalizes and metabolizes and comes back, like, really thoughtful, but I wish that he’d paused more in the moments and just been more thoughtful. I’m sure that we’re gonna have some good conversations after this, but I wish we [01:40:00] had good conversations with you in the room.
[01:40:02] Ramit: I appreciate that. Sean, I want to check in with you. What’s your reaction to Zoe’s comments about how she feels about the conversation that we had today?
[01:40:11] Sean: I’m disappointed that she’s disappointed because, yes, we weren’t as productive as we could have been, but I do think we made progress, and we opened the door for a few things.
[01:40:21] I also want to apologize to Remy because, um, yeah, I mean, my impulsivity has always gotten in the way of things, and I, I really, I feel like I need to just say what’s on my mind, and that’s not always the best idea right away. So, um, sorry for being a disappointment to both of you.
[01:40:40] Ramit: I appreciate that, Sean.
[01:40:41] It’s meaningful to hear you say that, and also, I never want to come down on anybody. That’s not why I bring people on this show. So I apologize because I think you mentioned you felt a little bit beat up upon. I can see that. That’s not my intention. I bring people on to help. And when I see potential, [01:41:00] which I can see because of the journeys both of you have been through, I want to push.
[01:41:04] And I am happy to hear some of the things we talked about in terms of the money should go towards savings, investments. I love that. This was a very surprising conversation for me for so many reasons. Sean has gone on a journey, the journey of recovery, and that to me is actually one huge point in favor of him being able to change when it comes to money.
[01:41:33] Compared to what he’s gone through, money is a much simpler thing to have to change. I hope he can apply some of the lessons that he has learned to his relationship with money, because it will take all of those skills to be able to bring them to bear here. I was a little surprised that Zoe had such strong words in her application, but as we started to have our conversation today, we spent so much time focusing on defensiveness and [01:42:00] resentment, and I suspect that’s actually what happens when they talk about money and they can’t even get to the really important parts.
[01:42:08] I actually want to apologize for potentially recreating that dynamic here, because even though they were pulling me in these directions, it’s my job to keep us focused on the big picture. In the end, Zoe said something very powerful and poignant where she said, “I kind of feel disappointed. I feel unresolved.”
[01:42:26] And I agree with that. I don’t see major changes that were made. I think there were a couple of points made here and there, but there was no shared understanding when we got to the end. There was love, but just the same way we started this conversation, money’s the one thing we can’t do, it ended in exactly the same way.
[01:42:46] When I started this 22 years ago I took it very personally. And in a way, I still do take my work personally, but I have learned something. For me, [01:43:00] pre-Netflix success was bring a couple or a person with money problems, do my razzmatazz, and fix it. They pay off their debt, they make $25,000 more, et cetera.
[01:43:12] I’ve realized now that that’s actually not my responsibility. Can I help them? Yes, I can help some people, but my job is to let people share their story, and I hope that they are receptive enough, open enough to take what I give them and change. Maybe they will do it, maybe not. I certainly hope they do because my greatest accomplishment in life is when people write back months or years later and say, “This is how you changed our life.
[01:43:40] This is what, what has happened.” So I hope they make the changes. I really do, and I would love to see what their follow-ups tell us.
[01:43:49] Sean: Hey, Sean here. Um, I wanna thank Ramit and team for having us on the podcast, and, um, what an interesting night that was. That gave me a lot to think about and a [01:44:00] lot to work on.
[01:44:00] It, it definitely gave me a, a chance to be more introspective and, um, to notice how I affect other people, especially people I care about the most, uh, like Zoe, of course. Um, so number one, I need to be more thoughtful in my approach to everything. I need to pause before reacting, especially if I’m feeling, like, emotionally charged, if I’m, if I’m really animated or whatever, um, which is what happens.
[01:44:28] I have ADHD, and it’s something that I kind of ignored for a while. I’m a person in recovery. Um, I don’t, I’m– I don’t really want to, uh, take any mind-altering substances. But when it comes down to it, if those things are hindering my life or impacting my goals and, um, other people’s goals around me, I need to address it, and that’s what I did.
[01:44:52] I, I talked to my doctor. I got on ADHD medicine. Seems to be working really well. I think that was a really, really good, um, point [01:45:00] that Ramit brought up, and I’m happy he did. Uh, another thing is that my definition of a provider is not only about making the most money. It’s about providing security, support, and, um, a, a life, emotional life, mental, and everything life to my partner and my future family.
[01:45:22] Um, I was always of the, the mindset that money equals providing. Well, that’s not always the case, and I’m glad that I, I was brought to light on that. In the meantime, uh, Zoe and I have had a few very constructive conversations. Um, we’re very openly communicative, and having been on that, that show really gave us a chance to collaborate and As, as, as messy as combining lives can be, especially when you’re coming from different areas and, and many different things, it’s worth it.
[01:45:58] And I’m really [01:46:00] glad that, uh, that, that we were given some tools to move forward with on this. I have hope now. One, one big takeaway too that I, I was surprised about, just one, one thing, um, that I send mixed messages and I don’t realize it. I, I think I’m explaining all sides of the situation or over– I’m overexplaining myself and it doesn’t matter at that point.
[01:46:23] All it does is confuse people. And, uh, I need to be more aware of how I communicate, so Um, thank you.
[01:46:32] Zoe: Hi, Ramit and team. Thank you again for the opportunity to be on the podcast and just for all of your efforts before, during, and after this experience of talking with Ramit. I think my biggest surprise was the conversation with Ramit felt like it was very narrow in terms of its focus.
[01:46:53] I don’t feel like, um, Sean and I got as far as I would’ve expected, and I was a little bit disappointed by that [01:47:00] at the time. But in retrospect, I felt like we got exactly what we needed out of the experience, which was to really see some of the patterns that come up in our relationship that make conversations about money difficult to have.
[01:47:15] On my side, my tendency to shrink myself and not really ask for what I want or need, and that predates my relationship with Sean. It has nothing to do with him, but it just sometimes comes out in that relationship, just as I think his defensiveness around money and some of his ADHD communication glitches have nothing to do with me.
[01:47:36] Um, but I think that the experience of talking with Ramit really brought those things to the forefront. I was also extremely surprised by how motivating and life-changing the process of just going through the numbers with Sean and doing our CSP was and how it inspired us to take changes even before we ever got into the Zoom room and had our [01:48:00] conversation.
[01:48:00] Um, so I liked that Sean and I both showed up to the conversation. I don’t love how we showed up, but we did learn a lot, and I’m grateful for that. Um, so here are the action items that I am taking and that we’re taking together. We have put an offer on a house that is smaller and less expensive than the house that I’m in now and, um, gotten an offer on my current house.
[01:48:27] And so hopefully six weeks from now, we’ll be in a different place, and that will help our finances quite a lot. Um, I also… The CSP inspired me to take a part-time job to make some additional income, which I’m excited about and I think Sean is a lot more supportive of. I think we both realized from the experience with Ramit that, um, I have a tendency to want him to chill out mentally, and he has a tendency to want me to chill out in terms of all the action that I take.
[01:48:56] And I think we both need to just give each other the space to be who we [01:49:00] are and to appreciate, um, what we bring to the table. Um, I’m also gonna be addressing some of my desire to make myself small and unobtrusive and unassuming in therapy, um, and to learn how to better ask for what I need without Trying to protect Sean’s feelings or other people’s feelings.
[01:49:23] Um, to that end, I’ve also had a really heart-to-heart conversation with my mom, and I think that we’re gonna be addressing some of the ways in which I feel like money is problematic
[01:49:33] Sean: in our relationship.
[01:49:34] Zoe: Yeah, I mean, there’s so much more that I could say, but I’m gonna stop the ramble and just say thank you again.
[01:49:42] I look forward to seeing where this experience is going to lead me and Sean, and while in the moment it brought up a lot of painful feelings, I think that, um, sitting with painful feelings is something that I really need to work on, and so it was a great opportunity. And, um, also, you [01:50:00] know, inspired us to take some really significant logistic actions, and, um, I’m looking forward to where this takes us.
[01:50:07] So thank you again, Ramit. Thank you to the team, and thank you to all of those who had to listen to our, uh, podcast conversation. I hope you were not as uncomfortable as I was. Um, all right. Thanks again. Bye.
[01:50:19] Sean: It’s been four weeks since our session, uh, with Ramit, and, um, yeah.
[01:50:26] Zoe: Yeah. And, um, I think some of the insights that have stuck with us the most have been our communication patterns and me being more clear and communicative and direct, and Sean vacillating a little less.
[01:50:43] Yeah. Um, yeah, so our communication’s definitely been better. We’ve had a lot of hard but constructive conversations- Mm-hmm … I would say. Um, and then Sean has made a lot of changes. Do you wanna
[01:50:56] Sean: share? Yeah. Yeah. I’m, I, I addressed my ADHD [01:51:00] thing. Mm. I started that. Um, I actually just signed up to get counseling too, um, therapy really, which is what I need to address a lot of things in my past, PTSD, uh, as well as a, a few other things that, um, that I can’t do on my own, honestly.
[01:51:16] So I’m outsourcing the help, and that was another suggestion from Ramit and team, and I, um, I greatly appreciate it. I am trying to take my time and pause and reflect before I, I open my mouth. A lot of times it’s, like, the impulsivity that gets me into trouble. And I love Zoe. I really love her, and I, I wanna be the best version of myself I can for her and for us.
[01:51:42] Um- Yeah … and we’re moving forward now.
[01:51:44] Zoe: Literally. We move in, uh, less than a week to the new house. Um, that’s really exciting. Sean’s been doing all of the logistics and the planning for the actual move. Um, and I will say the biggest challenge that [01:52:00] has hit us is that I found out that I’m getting laid off.
[01:52:03] Um, but I, um, next week I’ll have, um, my f- third, fourth, and fifth interview for other jobs. Um, I have a couple of months until my layoff sort of goes into effect and I get a three-month severance. So I think, you know, it could work out really well for us, but it’s a stressful time and I feel like our communication patterns, uh, have definitely been helping with that.
[01:52:27] Absolutely. So, um, yeah. We just- I like it … really, really appreciate the time, Ramit, with you and the sup- behind the scenes support of your team, and we will send another update after we’re in the new house, and I have a new job, and we can really sit down and re-crunch our numbers and do an updated CSP.
[01:52:48] Sean: It’s a really exciting time, and thank you, Ramit and team, for bringing these issues to light. I really appreciate it.
[01:52:54] Zoe: Okay. Bye.
[01:52:56] Ramit: I wanna thank our partners at Monarch again for setting my guests up with [01:53:00] one free year of the Monarch account so they can easily stay on the same page with money. If you want your own Monarch account with my exact conscious spending plan categories, go to monarch.com/ramit to try it for free, and get 50% off your first year of Monarch’s core tier with code Ramit.

 


#baby #income #spent

Leave a Comment